02-01-2008, 04:42 PM
i was watching the episode again and when hurley is in the police station lloking at the mirrior he sees the water then some1 swiming. when the person gets to the window he puts his hand on it. there is sumthing written on his hand. that would lead me to believe its charlie with "not pennies boat" but it looks like something different. i cnt quite figure it out but the last word looks like "you" any1 else c it?