Theory about Jacob's enemy

[wiley]

A very cool way to compose a theory.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V9ghX3vZHLg&feature=related

[losttime]

A very cool way to compose a theory.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V9ghX3vZHLg&feature=related


I liked this video Wiley. I had linked it sometime overthe summer because I was showing the connections between Smokey and Nemesis. I have felt they were the same for some time now.

You mayhave missed that post or whatever. Glad you liked it as well though

[Dharma Deviant]

WOW! That was great!!! That's my theory on smokie too.. Specially the part about Hurley's vision not being the same as the others. I think Hurley is getting messages from the other side. (not smokies)

[3d-aholic]

Actually at 5:32 what Locke says tends to dispell what he is theorizing. Why would Locke go about trying to create a "ruse" of saying he thought he was going to have to "convince" Ben to kill Jacob. Then he is surprised and it looks pretty genuine of what Alex told Ben. Since he already would have known that...all he would have to do is say, so what happened? No need to create a "convince ruse"...

At 5:55, it is further proof they are different. If Yemi was the smoke monster, he could have just converted right there to the smoke monster and killed Mr. Ecko...however, he had to run away and let the smoke monster do the dirty work. Same think in the case of the others, RA and the others have to kill for Jacob. Jacob is not allowed to kill directly...that is against the rules.

I think they both work on the same side towards the same goal but are independent. The smoke monster is to MiB as RA is to Jacob. They have the same goal but work independently towards that same goal in different ways.

Christian definetly is Nemesis and does not work for Jacob.