my theory - whats yours

[lastmel]

Hi

New to this,not even sure this is where I put it, but I'm sure somone will tell me soon enough, if its in the wrong place,so here goes :-

I think all the losties are still back on the Island except the Oceanic 6 ,who have agreed not to tell anyone that there freinds are still alive back on the Island.(no idea why though)

In the episode where jack was a drunk and called Kate about a funeral(it could have been Bens , Julliets, Desmond or anyone who was not on the plane) this episode Was Set in the Future. i.e a flash forward ,not a flash back,after being back for a while (no idea how long or why) Jack was desperate to go back to the Island and the person Katie was worried about leaving for too long was her son.

Siaid has realised Ben was telling the truth about "bad people" finding out about the Island and has been convinced by Ben that if he doesn't help to murder them,his friends on the Island (not Jack,Katie hurley ect) will all be in danger.

I was so shocked in this weeks episode that Kate's son was called Aaron,I do hope its Sawyers son and not Claires it woulds be alfull if somthing has happened to her as well as Charlie,however I think it is Claires son and that is why Jack has a problem with Kate having a baby,as he's probably found out it is his nephew and a reminder of his fathers affair.

Cant guess who the other 2 out of the six are,I had thought one would be Claire,as Desmond told Charlie he had had a vision of Claire getting onto the helicopter,with Aaron,if he went down to the looking glass and died,but that doesn't look likely now ? so maybe its Sun as Julliet has told us pregnant women die on the Island ?

Anyone esle got any theories on who they could be ?

[Kage]

Welcome Lostmel, I don't think Juliet is one of the "6" because she was not on the plane ,but that doesn't mean she didn't get off.Desmond and Juliet could have been rescued but not included in the Oceanic 6.I hope it's Sawyer's (ok James's )baby but doesn't look likely.Jack seems so desparate to get back,like he finally figured out leaving was not a smart idea.I think something may have happened to Claire and Jack feels responsible that's why he doesn't want to see Aaron.

[Snape]

The Aaron shown in Eggtown is 99% Claire's Aaron because of the age of the child. The only way to circumvent this is some time dilation (which I readily admit we're approaching) but I don't think so because time on the island (empirical chronological time) seems to agree with the outside world.

[suzisunshine1]

I just realized based on what one of you said about Juliet not being one of the 6 that Desmond wouldn't be considered one either b/c he wasn't on the plane. I feel like a total moron for not thinking of that before. So, that does leave two more people that would be included in the Oceanic 6.

Hmmm.....

[heavensprincess]

Hi

New to this,not even sure this is where I put it, but I'm sure somone will tell me soon enough, if its in the wrong place,so here goes :-

I think all the losties are still back on the Island except the Oceanic 6 ,who have agreed not to tell anyone that there freinds are still alive back on the Island.(no idea why though)

In the episode where jack was a drunk and called Kate about a funeral(it could have been Bens , Julliets, Desmond or anyone who was not on the plane) this episode Was Set in the Future. i.e a flash forward ,not a flash back,after being back for a while (no idea how long or why) Jack was desperate to go back to the Island and the person Katie was worried about leaving for too long was her son.

Siaid has realised Ben was telling the truth about "bad people" finding out about the Island and has been convinced by Ben that if he doesn't help to murder them,his friends on the Island (not Jack,Katie hurley ect) will all be in danger.

I was so shocked in this weeks episode that Kate's son was called Aaron,I do hope its Sawyers son and not Claires it woulds be alfull if somthing has happened to her as well as Charlie,however I think it is Claires son and that is why Jack has a problem with Kate having a baby,as he's probably found out it is his nephew and a reminder of his fathers affair.

Cant guess who the other 2 out of the six are,I had thought one would be Claire,as Desmond told Charlie he had had a vision of Claire getting onto the helicopter,with Aaron,if he went down to the looking glass and died,but that doesn't look likely now ? so maybe its Sun as Julliet has told us pregnant women die on the Island ?

Anyone esle got any theories on who they could be ?


I think the other two will be Sun and Jin. I think Claire will get on the helicopter with Aaron but something happens to her and that is how Kate ends up with Aaron. Who knows why Jack doesn't want to see the baby I only assume it's because he finds out that Claire is his sister and maybe there is some guilt or resentment. That doesn't even make sense to me but I can't think of any other reason why.

[lastmel]

I think the other two will be Sun and Jin. I think Claire will get on the helicopter with Aaron but something happens to her and that is how Kate ends up with Aaron. Who knows why Jack doesn't want to see the baby I only assume it's because he finds out that Claire is his sister and maybe there is some guilt or resentment. That doesn't even make sense to me but I can't think of any other reason why.


Hi
Yes I think one could be Sun , as the chances of her and her unborn baby surviving, after what julliet said are slim,if she doesn't get off the Island.But I'm still not sure about the 6th person,it could be any of the others Claire,Sawyer or Jinn.Maybe Claire's still alive on the Island? although I cannt think of any reason to give Aaron to Kate?

[suzisunshine1]

But since Sun became pregnant on the island, that was pretty much a one way ticket to certain death for her right? Isn't that what Juliet told her? Or are we hoping that if she gets off the island she'll be able to have the baby and they will both survive?

[heavensprincess]

But since Sun became pregnant on the island, that was pretty much a one way ticket to certain death for her right? Isn't that what Juliet told her? Or are we hoping that if she gets off the island she'll be able to have the baby and they will both survive?

That's what I'm hoping for if she gets off the island she will be able to deliver a healthy baby. I don't think it's known if they can deliver safely off the island. I kinda remember Juliet telling Ben that she needed to take a girl off the island to a hospital and him saying no.

[beachblinkette]

Jack looks like he's going to shoot someone accidently(like Ana Lucia did?) in the next show. Right before that they have Claire's face and she looks distressed. I think at some point Kate will protect Aaron thus when Claire dies Kate will stand in the gap. I've prob watched way too many "save my baby" shows!I hope the writers can write something unexpected here.All those fuzzy and not so fuzzy craniums must be able to put a new slant on it!

[islelost]

I just started on this site as well. Reading what you wrote something dawned on me. Why the hell would Kate end up with Claires baby and not his Uncle Jack. Now I really dont think it is Claires baby. This would be so out of character for Jack especially if he knows it is his nephew. Jack would never let Kate raise his family and keep his distance. No way. But im not the writer so we will see. I think it can be Sauyers or Kate had a son before the crash which Ive explained in other threads. I would bet one of those two before Claires baby. We know Jack better than that.

[Rain13]

The writers have said in interviews that he is 100% Claire's Aaron. There is no question about this.

[islelost]

But since Sun became pregnant on the island, that was pretty much a one way ticket to certain death for her right? Isn't that what Juliet told her? Or are we hoping that if she gets off the island she'll be able to have the baby and they will both survive?
Not to mention now with time delay or travel what ever it is this may not be Jins baby. The timing of the ultra sound could be off.

[Rain13]

A general question that may or may not pertain to what we're talking about :D: Do we consider the one sentence "episode summaries" that you see on TV Guide to be spoilers? Because they're always put up on wikipedia about 2-3 episodes in advance and I want to be sure they're not spoilers before I post one of them here. Again, I'm referring to the sentence-long episode descriptions you see on the TV Guide channel or when you press the "Info" button if you have DirectV/Comcast.

[islelost]

The writers have said in interviews that he is 100% Claire's Aaron. There is no question about this.
Where was this and if so then the writers changed Jacks character. He cares so much for everyone he would just give up his nephew unless he dosent know. Cant picture him seeing Kate at the airport and not asking about his family. The scene when he says we got to go back Kate. He dosent even ask about the kid. In the parking garage you would think he would say hey take care of him my family my blood. He must not know if the writers said it is Claires.

[Rain13]

I remembering seeing an interview with the writers where they said this and have seen numerous people mention it but I'm unable to find it online right now, can anyone back me up?

Also, neither Jack nor Claire have any knowledge that they are related right now, and we have no indication that they will ever even find out at all. Why are you assuming that Jack knows this when we see him in the flash forwards? In fact, wouldn't your insistance that Jack would never forget his kin be proof that he doesn't know Aaron is his nephew?

[islelost]

I remembering seeing an interview with the writers where they said this and have seen numerous people mention it but I'm unable to find it online right now, can anyone back me up?

Also, neither Jack nor Claire have any knowledge that they are related right now, and we have no indication that they will ever even find out at all. Why are you assuming that Jack knows this when we see him in the flash forwards? In fact, wouldn't your insistance that Jack would never forget his kin be proof that he doesn't know Aaron is his nephew?
Yeah that's what I said he must not know cause he would not let Kate the fugitive take his family. She can go to prison and then what would be of Arron.