well i would think this was a mistake but they don't make them there must be a reason

[rip-charlie]

I am rewatching all the shows i started with season 1 and I have made it to "in Translation" Jin just ran in the door and went to the restroom and started to wash his hand sun follow and asked what he did for her father. at 24:10 there is blood on the sleeve of his shrit at 25:16 there is not. I thought for a sec that it had to be a mistake but come on there has to be a reason the blood was gone they don't make mistakes like that.

[Ureval]

I think it was a mistake. Youre reading too much into it.

[rip-charlie]

I think it was a mistake. Youre reading too much into it.

i don't know for what this show is i don't think they make mistakes like this but i might be wrong reading to much into it that is what they want us to do and that is what i have been doing. oh well thanks

[jacksnurse]

yeah..prob not mistake....writers to smart...i still think that they must go on these sites from time to time and check out the crazy S##t that is posted...lol

[rip-charlie]

yeah..prob not mistake....writers to smart...i still think that they must go on these sites from time to time and check out the crazy S##t that is posted...lol

lol yeah so they can sit back and Laugh at us all...... lol

[zebu97]

I am rewatching all the shows i started with season 1 and I have made it to "in Translation" Jin just ran in the door and went to the restroom and started to wash his hand sun follow and asked what he did for her father. at 24:10 there is blood on the sleeve of his shrit at 25:16 there is not. I thought for a sec that it had to be a mistake but come on there has to be a reason the blood was gone they don't make mistakes like that.

I started watching them from the beginning again too and there is something I just noticed as well that doesn't make sense.

Right before the plane crashed, Charlie went up front to take some heroin and he was going to flush the rest when the "turbulence" hit. He left the drugs and was scrambling out of the bathroom and fell to the floor. About that time the drink cart started rolling towards him and he moved out of the way at the last minute and then crawled just a few rows back into a "leather" seat (first class????) and buckled himself in.

Which brings me to my question . . . how did Charlie end up on the beach when he was with the cabin section that crashed into the woods???? Remember how he went with Kate and Jack to the cabin portion to find the radio transceiver (and to get his drugs he left behind)???

Am I missing something????

[PolarBearonSkates]

The one "mistake" that bothers meis...The episode when when Jack swims out to save that woman (and ends up saving Boone), and Charlie says "i don't swim". Everytime I watch that episode i just GRRRRR!!!!

[rip-charlie]

The one "mistake" that bothers meis...The episode when when Jack swims out to save that woman (and ends up saving Boone), and Charlie says "i don't swim". Everytime I watch that episode i just GRRRRR!!!!

I don't think that was a mistake I think Charlie just didn't want to go and save her. I think he might have been high or just not cared. I don't think that was a mistake, something i just thought of what if well this is going to sound so stupid what if their past lifes changed while being on the island? what if Charlie didn't know he could swim until he remembered he could? I don't know I told you it was stupid.

[matt64345]

I started watching them from the beginning again too and there is something I just noticed as well that doesn't make sense.

Right before the plane crashed, Charlie went up front to take some heroin and he was going to flush the rest when the "turbulence" hit. He left the drugs and was scrambling out of the bathroom and fell to the floor. About that time the drink cart started rolling towards him and he moved out of the way at the last minute and then crawled just a few rows back into a "leather" seat (first class????) and buckled himself in.

Which brings me to my question . . . how did Charlie end up on the beach when he was with the cabin section that crashed into the woods???? Remember how he went with Kate and Jack to the cabin portion to find the radio transceiver (and to get his drugs he left behind)???

Am I missing something????

Well spotted but i think this is a mistake because something like this would of been answered before his death

[Panda]

I started watching them from the beginning again too and there is something I just noticed as well that doesn't make sense.

Right before the plane crashed, Charlie went up front to take some heroin and he was going to flush the rest when the "turbulence" hit. He left the drugs and was scrambling out of the bathroom and fell to the floor. About that time the drink cart started rolling towards him and he moved out of the way at the last minute and then crawled just a few rows back into a "leather" seat (first class????) and buckled himself in.

Which brings me to my question . . . how did Charlie end up on the beach when he was with the cabin section that crashed into the woods???? Remember how he went with Kate and Jack to the cabin portion to find the radio transceiver (and to get his drugs he left behind)???

Am I missing something????

I can't remember if he ended up directly on the beach.
Jack went to the beach after he woke up in the Jungle.
Maybe Charlie did the same, but we didn't see that.
Not everybody we see on the beach ended up there directly.
Some were in the water and had to swim to the beach, others landed in the jungle.
They just haven't shown us where every person was directly after the crash how they got to the beach
Thanks to this chaos it was easy for Ethan to infiltrate.
More than for Goodwin, as there everybody ended up in the sea except for the husband of rose who ended up in his chair in a tree.