Has Anyone Else Noticed...

[JfromtheD]

... that 99.9% of our theories, are wrong?!? :D

[JohnQ]

But I knew that MiB was Smokey right away. Of course, some people think I am a moron.

[stream]

... that 99.9% of our theories, are wrong?!? :D

what kind of thing is that to say JftD? I am going to take offense ;) and for the record I have never been right,
hell here at home everything is my fault, ask my husband, ask my oldest daughter, they will tell you, it is all my fault, even when I was not there

[myu]

But I knew that MiB was Smokey right away. Of course, some people think I am a moron.
Well that was just a bit easy, don't you think? Black tunic contrasting Jacob's white garb? Threatening to kill Jacob (projecting Smokey's behavior)? ;)

Yeah, there have been a lot of misses... but I'd say there's been a little better than 25% right so far. Wish I could claim a big piece of that, but I've only gotten 2 things right so far. :o

[JfromtheD]

25% Really??!? :eek::confused:

Wait. You're giving 22% to those who say "Lost" will pop up on the screen, aren't you? :D

[wiley]

I got the statue thing right, but I did have help, Arnzt told me.

[JfromtheD]

Somewhere, someone got 'Vincent is Jacob' right... :)

Don't even try to argue it! :mad:

[3d-aholic]

... that 99.9% of our theories, are wrong?!? :D

I think we should relable them Hypotheses.

[Junglist]

thats what makes the show good, and the messageboard fun to read.

though i do think the pumice statue debate is hilarious.

[Jeremy]

I've seen lots of others guess things right:

-that Locke was being used.

-it was Charles' boat and not Penny's coming to the island.

-Richard came on the Black Rock.

-Miles' dad was Cheng.

-Cooper the one responsible for Sawyer's parents' deaths.

-that there would be a new timeline to follow.

-that Charles and Eloise had something together.

-that Charles was Daniel's father.

-etc.

[stream]

I think we should relable them Hypotheses.

why, I can't spell either one right first try

thats what makes the show good, and the messageboard fun to read.

though i do think the pumice statue debate is hilarious.

what do you mean hilarious, that is serious sh%$!!!:eek:

[Junglist]

hilarious.

[JfromtheD]

I've seen lots of others guess things right:

-that Locke was being used.

-it was Charles' boat and not Penny's coming to the island.

-Richard came on the Black Rock.

-Miles' dad was Cheng.

-Cooper the one responsible for Sawyer's parents' deaths.

-that there would be a new timeline to follow.

-that Charles and Eloise had something together.

-that Charles was Daniel's father.

-etc.

Widmore's boat vs Penny's, saves you.
The rest I think were in the back of peoples heads...

[dead is dead]

watching vincent watching losties,ep.1

[sondez75]

not true....from the beginning i told everyone that the island was a cork holding the wine in so it wouldn't spill

[islander]

... that 99.9% of our theories, are wrong?!? :D

I think that number is too low :D

[notsolost42]

Somewhere, someone got 'Vincent is Jacob' right... :)

Don't even try to argue it! :mad:

Well, I think I know who is the biggest proponent of that theory. :)
Why, I've even been swayed now.

[Unbridled Pageantry]

not true....from the beginning i told everyone that the island was a cork holding the wine in so it wouldn't spill

hahaha, damn, that's some good intuition.

[Unbridled Pageantry]

thats what makes the show good, and the messageboard fun to read.

though i do think the pumice statue debate is hilarious.

I have new respect for the word Pumice.
Say it a few time, and it's rather soothing.

[natego]

thats what makes the show good, and the messageboard fun to read.

though i do think the pumice statue debate is hilarious.

Hilariously AWESOME!

[natego]

i have new respect for the word pumice.
Say it a few time, and it's rather soothing.

you're effin welcome.