Ben still with Jacob

[LOSTLOST]

the reason locke couldnt find jacob is becuz he is still with ben. i think he has been giving ben a plan on wut to do. as we saw last night it got him out of imprisonment. and how else would ben have relayed that information from hiself to the theropist, to juliet, if he was locked up?

[agmic]

so Jacob is with Ben...ummmm, but can't Locke also see Jacob?????? and if that's true, don't think Jacob is with Ben....

[beachblinkette]

Ben was reading a Philip K. Dick book just before he trapped John. Clearing the mind that way might allow him to come up with a new idea. Or was he inspired by the story in the book?You have to think that something in his mind is always screaming "More Coal! More coal!"

[LOSTLOST]

but how did ben communicate with the theropist? im thinking the theropist was jacob.

??

[Katesfishbiscuit]

i don't think jacob has a link to or is with ben. i think he is held captive and that's why he asks john for help. i think the therapist is the smoke monster and some how ben can manipulate it.

[Snape]

i don't think jacob has a link to or is with ben. i think he is held captive and that's why he asks john for help. i think the therapist is the smoke monster and some how ben can manipulate it.

This is my current theory to the letter. Isn't it nice to have collaboration when we haven't formerly communicated? Lends a little credence to what we both think is the case if we both came up with it independently.