Proof of the eye's owner

[Puga]

It is def Locke. I started to begin to think it wasn't based on what "eye" read here, but I think this is proof. The eye Hurley saw did appear to be brown, but now I'm thinking it's the lighting.

What does everyone think?

http://lost.cubit.net/

[enter38]

It is most definitely NOT Locke, its Jacob.

On the Season 3 DVD commentary on Man Behind The Curtain, Damon, Carlton and Michael Emerson discuss the episode, which includes Jacob and the eye. Which is the same eye that appears to Hurley.

There is no question after hearing the commentary that the eye is one way Jacob will be depicted.

There is another thread posted recently discussing this.

[Dzbabykel]

I saw that too and I think the show is trying to make us believe its Locke, hence having Locke be the one to show up right away after the door opens. I really don't think it is though, whatever eye we saw belonged to Jacob, an unknown actor we haven't seen yet.

[Ezekiel 25:17]

UUUUUUUUUUUUGGGGGGGGHHHHHHH!!!!!!! Are u people ever gonna let some of this stuff go LOL!!!!!! Dude, JACOB and JOHN LOCKE are 2/two/dos/twa/duo/deux/di, 2 2 2 2 2 totally different people TWOOOOOO, for whatever language anyone speaks just so they understant. I thought everyone knew LOL, just kidding, ANYHOW, if the "eye of the island" belongs to John Locke, how could John Locke see the eye of the island. It's Jacobs, and yes a bunch of other random people sit in the chair every different time, and there will be more, way more. O man this stuff is just getting warmed up!:D

[Dzbabykel]

Haha you gonna be ok Ezekial?!?!? Lol jk :) I agree with ya.