Why would you kill Juliet?

[UnknownPoster]

She said if they knew what she had done they would killer.

What did she mean?
________
Honda motocompo history (http://www.honda-wiki.org/wiki/Honda_Motocompo)

[krakup]

i think she said something like if she told Sayid evth she knew he would kill her. mayb cause he would have no need of her after or maybe it is something sinister in the past. guess we have to wait and see

[Qilla]

this is how i c it -

in season 2, anna lucia kills goodwin after she discovers that he was an other and in season 3 you find out that juilet & goodwin were lovers, so im thinkin that when michael was captured in season 2 by the others & was given that list on who to bring back to them, juilet made her own lil request & that was to have anna lucia killed.............which also lead to libby gettin killed

if that all turns out to be true - i think it's enough reason 4juliet to be worried!!!!

[stream]

this is good, I don't think this has been discussed much, they were together, Juliet n Goodwin, and that could have been part of Michael's instructions, I never thought of that, but looking back it is quite possible

[Ezekiel 25:17]

That makes a lot of sense. Why would Mikey kill Anna Lucia, I get it now. Juliet wanted her dead and had mike kill her. But there is only one problem with that theory. The others didn't know that Anna lucia killed goodwin. She didn't tell anyone but Cindi Ecko Libby and Bernard. No one from the back half of the plane knew. And.. oh WAIT!!! Cindi knew and the others kidnapped her I just answered my own question, srry should've thought through that first, maybe I'll save other people the thought. Good theory I bet thats the way it turns out good call

[1hourisntlongenough]

this is how i c it -

in season 2, anna lucia kills goodwin after she discovers that he was an other and in season 3 you find out that juilet & goodwin were lovers, so im thinkin that when michael was captured in season 2 by the others & was given that list on who to bring back to them, juilet made her own lil request & that was to have anna lucia killed.............which also lead to libby gettin killed

if that all turns out to be true - i think it's enough reason 4juliet to be worried!!!!

This is interesting!!:eek: I hadn't even thought of this..... Hopefully we'll get many answers this week.

[Lost in VA]

Juliet is a good person deep down, she just wants to get off the Island.

[Turnip Queen]

Oooh that's a very good theory! I think you could very well be right! And we haven't seen a flash-forward of Juliet yet, and she's already had her episode, so maybe she's marked!

[phoenix13]

guys I DIDNT WATCH seasan 3 yet but I saw her in youtube and videos she is ugly and I hate her coz she steel jack from kate so backoff juliett jack is for kate:)

[Turnip Queen]

guys I DIDNT WATCH seasan 3 yet but I saw her in youtube and videos she is ugly and I hate her coz she steel jack from kate so backoff juliett jack is for kate:)


HAHAHA Ah no,I don't think it's fair to say Juliet is ugly, I think she's really pretty, and I have warmed to her over time, I didn't trust her for a long time but right now I do. I just don't like her for her adulterous ways!

[rip-charlie]

guys I DIDNT WATCH seasan 3 yet but I saw her in youtube and videos she is ugly and I hate her coz she steel jack from kate so backoff juliett jack is for kate:)

i don't think kate should be with Jack she is good with James (sawyer) that is who i want her to end up with but he is not one of the 6 so i know that is not going to be :( don't get me wrong i think Jack is Sexy but there is something about a bad boy i can't say no too. lol

[Turnip Queen]

i don't think kate should be with Jack she is good with James (sawyer) that is who i want her to end up with but he is not one of the 6 so i know that is not going to be :( don't get me wrong i think Jack is Sexy but there is something about a bad boy i can't say no too. lol
Damn right! I swear, I hope the writers know that if they killed Sawyer women everywhere would be devastated, it would be the worst thing they could do!

[Ladihawke]

I agree that Huliet is as much a prisoner as any of them. She just wants to go home. She may have had do do some vile things for Ben, but she isn't a bad person.

[maryb]

this is how i c it -

in season 2, anna lucia kills goodwin after she discovers that he was an other and in season 3 you find out that juilet & goodwin were lovers, so im thinkin that when michael was captured in season 2 by the others & was given that list on who to bring back to them, juilet made her own lil request & that was to have anna lucia killed.............which also lead to libby gettin killed

if that all turns out to be true - i think it's enough reason 4juliet to be worried!!!!

I don't think that is why Michael shoots Ana Lucia...I think she was just in the way of him freeing Ben.......Remember Ana Lucia was going to shoot Ben but couldn't (only Michael and Ana were in the room)...His opportunity to free Ben, He said he would do it...instead shoots Ana Lucia, Lily walks in and he without thought shoots her too.........Ben is free........Michael did his job for the others!

[Hurley's Left Sock]

I don't think that is why Michael shoots Ana Lucia...I think she was just in the way of him freeing Ben.......Remember Ana Lucia was going to shoot Ben but couldn't (only Michael and Ana were in the room)...His opportunity to free Ben, He said he would do it...instead shoots Ana Lucia, Lily walks in and he without thought shoots her too.........Ben is free........Michael did his job for the others!

Yes, this is pretty much how I see it.
I suppose it's not impossible that Juliet has given Michael some instructions to specifically kill Ana Lucia in revenge for the death of Goodwin, but that would mean he had two separate missions, meaning twice the chance of failure.
Michael's primary objective is to free Ben. He doesn't know who will be in the Swan guarding Ben at the time. If he were to try and kill Ana Lucia first then that could jepordise his mission to rescue Ben. We have to assume that the Others would not put Ben in that kind of danger simply for Juliet's personal revenge. I think it is as simple as you said, Michael has to break Ben out and he has to kill anyone who might interefere with that. Ana Lucia is simply in the wrong place at the wrong time, as was Libby.

guys I DIDNT WATCH seasan 3 yet but I saw her in youtube and videos she is ugly and I hate her coz she steel jack from kate so backoff juliett jack is for kate
Nah, Kate has been having it her own way for too long. She's like a kid in a sweet shop, playing Jack and Sawyer off against each other for her affections which has only grew her already over-inflated ego. Juliet's rivalry for Jack's affections have given Kate her own competition and a taste of her own medicine. She doesn't like it one bit and I'm glad she isn't getting everything her own way now :D