What Hurley said...

[lasr]

I've been thinking about what Hurley was talking about, that these flash forewards aren't real and they're actually dead, and I was wondering if they are true or not. Could it be that that truly is heaven? But how would Kate be talking to Sawyer on the island then? This is an interesting twist.

[stargazer]

I don't think its heaven, seems more like hell. And Kate wasn't talking to Sawyer. She was arranging a meeting with someone on behalf of Sawyer.

[mahalo_dude]

Hurley's doctor said something to the effect of "He thinks I'm imaginary" to Jack. I don't think they are dead in the flashforwards. There's something else that I can't put my finger on yet.

[1hourisntlongenough]

I don't think its heaven, seems more like hell. And Kate wasn't talking to Sawyer. She was arranging a meeting with someone on behalf of Sawyer.

Definitely NOT talking to Sawyer...for sure was talking to someone about meeting up. (prob about Clementine....) And remember when Jack said to Hurley that just because he was happy doesn't mean he's dead....and Hurley said back, yea I was happy once too.....What was it that made him unhappy? Was it because he started seeing Charlie?

[imascootinspook]

Definitely NOT talking to Sawyer...for sure was talking to someone about meeting up. (prob about Clementine....) And remember when Jack said to Hurley that just because he was happy doesn't mean he's dead....and Hurley said back, yea I was happy once too.....What was it that made him unhappy? Was it because he started seeing Charlie?

The only thing I can think of is, He was happy on the island.....I can't recall any FF or FB's where he has been happy except that small time he had the lottery money and nothing bad happened yet.

[wvugurl]

ok kate was taking care of something for sawyer that apparently i am assuming that she promised as he decided to stay on the island...ah ha we know sawyer is alive...

ok onto hurley...i am not sure...on one hand i want to say he is just nuts..no one else is seeing charlie...the other dr did not see jacks dad...so how are they dead???...i think its just another interesting curve ball to say what the hell...

but then on the other hand...im not sure (if hurleys comment is taken to heart) means nec they are actually dead...it could mean something with the time stuff (that we cannot figure out) and maybe all of them did not leave the island in the time they should have-present time...

[2boyzmom]

I am wondering if they are in purgatory...it is what Hurley said...

[wvugurl]

I am wondering if they are in purgatory...it is what Hurley said...

he said that tonite???

[imascootinspook]

he said that tonite???

In a round about way he was questioning it but we know that it's not purgatory!

[wvugurl]

In a round about way he was questioning it but we know that it's not purgatory!

i did not catch that..but will rewatch with my oldest son tomorrow

[imascootinspook]

i did not catch that..but will rewatch with my oldest son tomorrow
It was basically his whole conversation with Jack.