Does anyone else think Claire was acting funny?

[rip-charlie]

I keep thinking about Claire in the cabin last night he smile looked creepy! she said I'm with him not even worried about aaron. my question is is she dead or what?

[bunnydixon]

yes her mannerism were quite different.

[Jezz15]

I keep thinking about Claire in the cabin last night he smile looked creepy! she said I'm with him not even worried about aaron. my question is is she dead or what?

Not to sure if she is dead or if she has just lost her mind. She gave that odd looking smile that made me think she needed to join Hurley.

[thelawgiver]

Two posibilities:

1. High

2. Enlightened as to what it is all about

[freefallenferrari]

I think that Claire is dead, she was acting very funny, she was all dirty, she did not at all seem concerned about Aaron and she was sitting there with Jack's (and her own) dead father.

[imascootinspook]

Yes she definitely got ahold of some happy pills or something.

[cdnlostaddict]

I am new to the site and I just re watched the last two episodes on ctv.ca and I think Claire is dead - she said that she was feeling better but had a headache, concussion maybe and because she fell alseep, maybe she died in her sleep??

[bunnydixon]

Two posibilities:

1. High

2. Enlightened as to what it is all about


maybe a little of both ;)

[Cous4th]

Can the island re-animate dead bodies? I remember that Christian's coffin was found empty, and I guess that Claire could have actually died in the explosion, and Miles knew it when he looked at her

[1hourisntlongenough]

I'm sorry to say it but I'm thinking she's dead.:(
She was way too comfortable in the cabin with Christian and acted very nonchalant with Locke as he entered...even reassuring him that Aaron was fine and was right where he needed to be. (which apparently means NOT with her) VERY out of character for her.:(

[Jezz15]

I know that they have made some big jumps on this show...but to go from her sleeping and then waking up to her father to being dead in a cabin is a HUGE jump for them. They usually explain in detail when and how someone gets killed. I don't want to say or even believe that she is dead yet.

[badbrainz]

y does everyone think shes dead?
theres absolutley nothing supporting that hypoyhosis
so she was chillin with a ghost
locke could see tha ghost but hes not dead
i think she was happy cuz she knows what is going on

[thelawgiver]

Can you really be sure it is Claire? Was it just some Jacob or Smoke Monster manifestation of Claire? But I do like the idea that maybe she died in her sleep and is now part of the undead (with Christian) wondering the island.

[bunnydixon]

i am still working on the idea that her body is being used by someone/something else...

[Existentialist]

Oh yes. Claire had that wierd smile. She was with her father, who is dead. Also, the baby was not with her, and she was very calm. Usually she is totally protective of the baby, ever vigilant of his whereabouts. I think she really did get killed in the explosion.

[erock]

Every time i have an idea as to what is really happening it gets crushed.

[Missie]

Ok, I think she is dead but because I do not want her to die I came up with another solution.

She knows it all now because of Christian and she knows that Aaron is the next chosen one. But being just a baby he cant take over the island right now, so Locke (the orignal chosen one) has to fix Ben's (the chosen one in Lockes absense) mess until Aaron is old enough to be the new chosen one. Claire knows all this and is helping her father dish out the plan to Locke.

Or she got ahold of some of the muddy stuff locke made in his sweat lodge and is enjoying the ride.

[Missie]

Every time i have an idea as to what is really happening it gets crushed.

That just makes you a true LOST fan.

[danielle222]

Claire was acting very weird. I don't think she's dead, though. Maybe she's under some kind of hypnosis. She was definitely not herself.

[JJ McAbraham]

I definitely think she is dead. Emilie de Raven just finished shooting a movie a few months ago and is currently filming a movie called Public Enemies. Her character did not have any new developments and her backstory was dry after the only episode that addressed her life... well maybe there was two. I believe her time is done.

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

I definitely think she is dead. Emilie de Raven just finished shooting a movie a few months ago and is currently filming a movie called Public Enemies. Her character did not have any new developments and her backstory was dry after the only episode that addressed her life... well maybe there was two. I believe her time is done.

You're absolutely right, JJ. Claire is dead. My question is how come our undead Losties are so complacent... It seems everything has become quite clear to all of them and they only appear the the rest in order to bring a warning or to guide them. ... You know, I don't think Josh Holloway will leave, but he did recently make (yet another) spook movie and then I always wonder if they're leaving the show when I see this, like Emily de Raven.

[navyguy]

I definitely think she is dead. Emilie de Raven just finished shooting a movie a few months ago and is currently filming a movie called Public Enemies. Her character did not have any new developments and her backstory was dry after the only episode that addressed her life... well maybe there was two. I believe her time is done.

I do not think Claire is dead. That is a crappy way to kill someone off. This show is just too great for someone to pass away at rest. As for her character developments, the producers have said starting in "Something Nice Back Home" there is a very interesting Claire storyline beginning. Yes Emile did shoot a movie a couple months ago WHEN LOST WASN'T FILMING, and also remember they are trying to push Lost until 2011 i believe if not 2010, so there is probably going to be another long hiatus before season 5, which gives opportunities for many of the actors to be in major motion pictures.

Does Vantage Point and Speed Racer mean Matthew Fox has left the show? Nope. Don't think so. that is not a proper assumption.

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

about the undead Losties and undead in general on our show...
Remember Zombie Girl, daughter of the psychic? Remember her saying,
"It's only when you're between places that you find what you're looking for"
(with U2 background music. lol) Maybe that's why they all seem content and understand the essence of it all. Anyone???

[sirchin]

Her face looked fatter! I think she is rettaining water............salt water.....
as for being high maybe the cabin is like a sweat tent, maybe a little peoti. Christian looked awful happy too! LOL!

[JohnnieGo]

Remember when Locke pushed the Other into the electric fence and he later pops back up later.

I think she's dead too. The Asian guy can talk to dead people and he was the one who saw Claire leave. A friend of mine said the preview for the episode when Claire disappears said that one of the survivors would die (I didn't see the preview, but it makes sense).

Claire's baby has been a big part of the plot, so maybe the island chooses who will be re-animated and who will die.

[rip-charlie]

i don't know I just keep thinking about the Smile... it kinda looked evil. I don't know if she isa dead or not. I hope not some day she might get her son back but i can't get the image of that smile out of my head. Strange i know. sorry

[tsolfan]

Yeah, I think she's totally dead. Or as "dead" as you can be on the island.

[danielle222]

Her face looked fatter! I think she is rettaining water............salt water.....
as for being high maybe the cabin is like a sweat tent, maybe a little peoti. Christian looked awful happy too! LOL!

I noticed that, too. But I think it was just a bad angle.

[danielle222]

Yes Emile did shoot a movie a couple months ago WHEN LOST WASN'T FILMING, and also remember they are trying to push Lost until 2011 i believe if not 2010, so there is probably going to be another long hiatus before season 5, which gives opportunities for many of the actors to be in major motion pictures.

Does Vantage Point and Speed Racer mean Matthew Fox has left the show? Nope. Don't think so. that is not a proper assumption.

Are you saying they are going to push season five out a couple years?! I will freak out if that happens.

I agree it is not a proper assumption that just because a TV actor is filming a movie means he or she is leavinig a show. It happens all the time in the entertainment industry.

[JASYMORRI]

Have to say she did seem very different and also look odd. Something certainly not right there but then again leaving your baby in the jungle and ending up in a cabin god knows where with someone that is actually dead.......

[rip-charlie]

Are you saying they are going to push season five out a couple years?! I will freak out if that happens.

I agree it is not a proper assumption that just because a TV actor is filming a movie means he or she is leavinig a show. It happens all the time in the entertainment industry.

I hope we don't have to wait that long i hate the long breaks.

[chococat512]

maybe now that claire is dead her and charlie can be together cuz he's dead too! haha

i fully support the idea of her being dead, after all dead characters are constantly popping up on lost (boone, libby, charlie, patchy, horace...)

how come we dont see other characters that are "dead" like Eko or Shannon?

[jacksnurse]

I'm sorry to say it but I'm thinking she's dead.:(
She was way too comfortable in the cabin with Christian and acted very nonchalant with Locke as he entered...even reassuring him that Aaron was fine and was right where he needed to be. (which apparently means NOT with her) VERY out of character for her.:(

thats exactly what i was thinking 1hour!!!! that would then explain how aaron ends up with kate...i think that bunnys idea of being high is possible too....i want some of that...lol

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

Every time i have an idea as to what is really happening it gets crushed.

Hey! You're not alone! I think we all have ideas that seem perfectly logical...
until someone else sounds better and we're left with an Excedrin headache!
lol Don't ever feel bad about stating what you think, asking questions you fear are dumb, or just plain needing to vent about something. That's why we have this forum and everyone's thoughts are well received (long as you NEVER say you hate LOST and hate the forum, in which case we will all start looking for Eko's Jesus stick... lol kidding) :)

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

Her face looked fatter! I think she is rettaining water............salt water.....
as for being high maybe the cabin is like a sweat tent, maybe a little peoti. Christian looked awful happy too! LOL!

ok, I'm yet a third person who thought the same. Her face looked fatter.
I thought she looked fatter all over. Maybe Emilie is pregnant and now is a good time to leave the show.... ??

[Turnip Queen]

I think it was the moment I saw Claire that I really felt frightened about the fate of everyone on that island - if she's not dead then she's in some sort of trance - it was freaky! And what about Locke's dream about Horace? It was kinda repeating like a bad film or something - is he gonna appear in reality - cos we can see his rotted corpse in the ground. And if Claire died in the explosion, then she only started acting differently now - so did she die overnight or something? What does Miles know about this???

[sirchin]

TQ said, "What does Miles know about this??"


I say, "That's what I wanna know! That little twirp knows more than he's saying"

[Turnip Queen]

TQ said, "What does Miles know about this??"


I say, "That's what I wanna know! That little twirp knows more than he's saying"

Definitely! I hope we see some of Sawyer talking to him next week and have some answers! Miles is the key to everything!

[JJ McAbraham]

I do not think Claire is dead. That is a crappy way to kill someone off. This show is just too great for someone to pass away at rest. As for her character developments, the producers have said starting in "Something Nice Back Home" there is a very interesting Claire storyline beginning. Yes Emile did shoot a movie a couple months ago WHEN LOST WASN'T FILMING, and also remember they are trying to push Lost until 2011 i believe if not 2010, so there is probably going to be another long hiatus before season 5, which gives opportunities for many of the actors to be in major motion pictures.

Does Vantage Point and Speed Racer mean Matthew Fox has left the show? Nope. Don't think so. that is not a proper assumption.

I guess you know everything.

[sirchin]

I hope Sawyer has to kick Mile's ass to get the info. It's about that time for someone to get their ass kicked. Speaking of asskicking Jack is waaaaaaaaaay overdue. I hope either Sawyer kicks his ass over Kate, or Locke kick's his ass for trying to kill him.
Orrrrrr..... Ben kicks his ass for the ass kicking he gave him. Hell I'd be happy if the dog just bit him!

[JJ McAbraham]

I hope Sawyer has to kick Mile's ass to get the info. It's about that time for someone to get their ass kicked. Speaking of asskicking Jack is waaaaaaaaaay overdue. I hope either Sawyer kicks his ass over Kate, or Locke kick's his ass for trying to kill him.
Orrrrrr..... Ben kicks his ass for the ass kicking he gave him. Hell I'd be happy if the dog just bit him!

Asskicking.


Sorry, it needed to be said one more time hahaha. I agree though. Someone needs a swift kick to the teeth.

[gingergrant]

I agree, Claire definitely looked strange. She had that "I don't care about anything attitude", NOT Claire.

When Sawyer pulled the pieces off of Claire after the explosion, didn't she just sit up pretty quickly?

at the time, I sort of felt that the island just healed her very quickly.

[wvugurl]

im not so sure she is dead yet....it has been said a character would die and we would still see alot of them...maybe this is it...i think her face was just a bad angle and her kind of slouching in the chair...but christian has obivisouly convenienced her of this (where aaron needs to be) and she may just be happy to see her dad...strange yes...but this show is strange

[gingergrant]

but this show is strange

and that's why we LOVE it!

[wvugurl]

and that's why we LOVE it!

my point exactly;)

[lost_in_iowa]

Have to say she did seem very different and also look odd. Something certainly not right there but then again leaving your baby in the jungle and ending up in a cabin god knows where with someone that is actually dead.......

i have noticed Claire has been wearing a wig in the show for quite a while. did she dye her hair in real life or cut it?

anyway, if she is or is not dead, maybe she is "reappearing" from the "future".

[mhzmike]

I keep thinking about Claire in the cabin last night he smile looked creepy! she said I'm with him not even worried about aaron. my question is is she dead or what?

about an all new "LOST".....

if you look closely, this scene was filmed when Emile de Ravland ( Claire) was actually pregnant........more to come

[rip-charlie]

about an all new "LOST".....

if you look closely, this scene was filmed when Emile de Ravland ( Claire) was actually pregnant........more to come

that must be why her face looked chubby! thanks for the info!

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

TQ said, "What does Miles know about this??"


I say, "That's what I wanna know! That little twirp knows more than he's saying"

I think he does, too! Let's go ring his doorbell!!!
Better yet, I think Sayid should go ring his doorbell...

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

I do not think Claire is dead. That is a crappy way to kill someone off. This show is just too great for someone to pass away at rest. As for her character developments, the producers have said starting in "Something Nice Back Home" there is a very interesting Claire storyline beginning. Yes Emile did shoot a movie a couple months ago WHEN LOST WASN'T FILMING, and also remember they are trying to push Lost until 2011 i believe if not 2010, so there is probably going to be another long hiatus before season 5, which gives opportunities for many of the actors to be in major motion pictures.

Does Vantage Point and Speed Racer mean Matthew Fox has left the show? Nope. Don't think so. that is not a proper assumption.

NAVYGUY!!... IT'S ME, LOCKE!... I'M WITH JJ!... WE'RE APPROCHING THE THREAD!....don't shoot us....
We were merely making an observation based on how her charactor's been going:)

[Turnip Queen]

im not so sure she is dead yet....it has been said a character would die and we would still see alot of them...maybe this is it...i think her face was just a bad angle and her kind of slouching in the chair...but christian has obivisouly convenienced her of this (where aaron needs to be) and she may just be happy to see her dad...strange yes...but this show is strange

I'm hoping she's not dead yet either - she's acting REALLY strangely - BUT she was acting normally until the cabin! Maybe the cabin has some sort of power like that, God I just don't know anymore!!

[marx7]

Remember when Claire was kidnapped by Ethan and he was giving her the drugged water? That's what she looked like. It was a bit strange. And didn't Christian look like he lost weight?

[stargazer]

I think her brains have been sucked out....

[Diamond Girl]

Claire did look like she was in a catatonic state or trance. I can't believe she left Aaron alone in the jungle. That is so out of character for her. Could she have perhaps spent some time in Room 23? I think perhaps she may now have some special powers which were caused by the explosion. While walking through the jungle with Sawyer and Miles, she said she was feeling woozy, but at least she wasn't seeing things anymore. What things was she seeing?

[danielle222]

I think everyone on this thread has made really good points. If Claire died in the explosion then why is she just now starting to act strange? Also, about her face being chubby, that was obviously intentional by the writers. I've said this in a previous post, but it was really a bad angle. When you're slouching in a chair or couch, most people will have a double chin. It was intentional.

[Turnip Queen]

What bothers me and what makes me scared that she's dead is that Christian says something like 'You'd best not tell anyone you saw her here' to Locke - why is that - because someone's gonna see her dead body somewhere or something?

[RynG78]

I think that it has something to do with her not raising the baby. Remember the psychic said she is not supposed to raise Aaron. If they founf out Claire was there they would go look for her.

[rip-charlie]

I think that it has something to do with her not raising the baby. Remember the psychic said she is not supposed to raise Aaron. If they founf out Claire was there they would go look for her.

no i don't think that was right he said "NO ONE BUT HER WAS TO RAISE THE BABY"

[Diamond Girl]

Yes, the psychic stated that Aaron is not to be raised by another. Charlie's message to Jack via Hurley also stated, "You're not supposed to raise him." I think this is one of the reasons why Jack and Kate must return to the island with Aaron.

I agree with the posters who stated that Claire looked chubby or pregnant while in Jacob's cabin. Maybe when Claire was still pregnant w/Aaron and Christian Shepard was still very much alive, they traveled into the future to deliver their message to Locke. Maybe that's why they told Locke that Aaron is exactly where he should be because he was still in the womb. But wouldn't Locke have noticed if Claire was pregnant? :confused:

[coldandevell]

As you are discussing this I keep flashing back to thoughts of The Others guy in New York telling Michael (and I loosely paraphrase) until your mission is done the island won't let you die. And then I see Christian Shepard and thoughts of time travel and the island run through my head. He was a big doctor, who knows what else he was involved in in his life that could have led him to the island and its mysteries After all he apparently had a secret family in Australia no one knew about. And as someone pointed out in another thread a lot of doctors were brought to the island.

I think Claire looked like someone had enlightened her to a few things. (you know lots of things we have not been enlightened to yet lol) Perhaps she was not worried about Aaron because after all that she was told she felt the island was going to protect him.

[Archangel-Player]

I don't think Claire is dead and I kinda have my doubts about Christine's state of being as well.
My opion. This same senario has happen to Clair before. She myteriously goese off with a man first time Eithan and now her father. Both times she mad a decision for Aaron to be left behind to someone else. in that case Arraon was still in the woom. So she wa sgoingto agree to letthem cut him out and was happey and excited about her choice that was in episode "Maternity leave" Which we later found out that Eithan had druged her with a syerum said it was for her and teh baby to not get sick. Ovcourse we teh audience kne wbetter. It seems she is under soem type of sadation this time around. Though I don't belive Christin druge dher like eithan. this time I belive she is under some type of transe like soemone has the power of manipulation on her. Either Smokie or Jacob Or like said above she totaly understands what is going on now and has accepted her place as well as Arran's. Im sticking with she is under some type of mind hold. Because last time we saw Christine in Jacob's house. It was confirmed that it was Smokey and we all know what kind of power Smokie has showed us. We know he can view your inner thoughts and possably manipulate your mind kinda like he manipulated Eko into thinking it was his brother before killing him. :-) That's just my thoughts.
Also
Maybe it's not Jacob's wish to move the island perhaps it was Smokie's idea and that would be why the O6 are unhappey and disturbed in the Flash Fwds. Because they where foolish enough to folow the plan or It was Jacob's idea and the O6 chose to folow the freighter crew's plan of escape instead of what Jacob wanted.