Claire....

[coffefrap]

Is she dead? Or is she just hanging with her dad...I don't understand why she is with him....I thought she did not want to see him -- confused -- :confused: And, I don't understand why Christian told Locke that "Aaron was where he was supposed to be" when the psychic lady told Claire that she was not to allow anyone else to raise her baby -- she had to be the one to raise Aaron.....can anyone clear that up or have I again, missed a major point......help!

[addictedtopainmeds]

Is she dead? Or is she just hanging with her dad...I don't understand why she is with him....I thought she did not want to see him -- confused -- :confused: And, I don't understand why Christian told Locke that "Aaron was where he was supposed to be" when the psychic lady told Claire that she was not to allow anyone else to raise her baby -- she had to be the one to raise Aaron.....can anyone clear that up or have I again, missed a major point......help!

"they are coming to take me away haha! they are coming to take me away"!

[Panda]

Maybe you can read in this topic about it.

http://www.lost.com/forum/showthread.php?t=3224&highlight=claire+isn%27t+dead

and here another one that started the subject before.

http://www.lost.com/forum/showthread.php?t=3444&highlight=claire

the search is so easy to use you know.

[cheapshot11b]

dead and hanging with her dad.

what creeps me out thye most is how dark it was in the cabin. couldn't they at least get a TV or Nintendo DS?

you're not he only one confused...the major point is MIA

[notsolost42]

When Claire said "I'm okay I'm with him now" I thought it was very eerie and creepy. The way she said it! If I'm right and Christian is dead and alive then he is screwed up so maybe she is too. They are both kind of "undead".

One further thought on this. It's kind of like Stephen King's "Pet Cemetary". Dead and back alive but not quite right. Just a little off.

[ortrules]

She's totally alive...something else has happened to her to put her in that trance like state, but she is alive.

[notsolost42]

Oh Ort, here we go again! Let's agree to disagree!

[Panda]

Oh Ort, here we go again! Let's agree to disagree!

Well I agree with that!!!!
I posted the links to the topics where we went trough all this, just to avoid a time loop over here.

So people check out the links first. So that people don't have to repeat themselves in eternity. Thx

[Tommy17]

I thought itn was a man not a lady that told Claire about a safe place for Aaron

[ortrules]

Let's agree to disagree!

Never!!! :D

[cheapshot11b]

I thought itn was a man not a lady that told Claire about a safe place for Aaron

yaya, itn was-Richard Malkin

[lostlindy]

When Clair, Sawyer and Miles are heading back to the beach, Sawyer asks her if she's O.K. and she replies something to the effect ,I'm O.K., at least *I'm not SEEING things anymore* HHMMM :rolleyes:

[danielle222]

Well I agree with that!!!!
I posted the links to the topics where we went trough all this, just to avoid a time loop over here.

So people check out the links first. So that people don't have to repeat themselves in eternity. Thx

Then don't respond if you don't want to. :p

[ortrules]

Well I agree with that!!!!
I posted the links to the topics where we went trough all this, just to avoid a time loop over here.

So people check out the links first. So that people don't have to repeat themselves in eternity. Thx

Don't tell me what I can't do! :D

[notsolost42]

Well I agree with that!!!!
I posted the links to the topics where we went trough all this, just to avoid a time loop over here.

So people check out the links first. So that people don't have to repeat themselves in eternity. Thx

Panda, thanks for your input but I was making an inside joke to Ort. You see, Ort always plays my "Devils Advocate" when I start bouncing theories around. We have had a long running debate between ourselves about Claire. I was actually making a joke to Ort and it wasn't that I was making a statement to the thread. People come here to debate all the time and we, as Horace did, repeat ourselves quite often. It happen's. So what. Anyway, I apologize if you mistook what I said.

[ortrules]

Panda, thanks for your input but I was making an inside joke to Ort. You see, Ort always plays my "Devils Advocate" when I start bouncing theories around. We have had a long running debate between ourselves about Claire. I was actually making a joke to Ort and it wasn't that I was making a statement to the thread. People come here to debate all the time and we, as Horace did, repeat ourselves quite often. It happen's. So what. Anyway, I apologize if you mistook what I said.
Right. And Claire is alive.

Apology accepted. :D

[notsolost42]

Right. And Claire is alive.

Apology accepted. :D

Hey, that was for Panda not you....
She's dead, get over it. OMG, people are so touchy about Claire!

[danielle222]

Hey, that was for Panda not you....
She's dead, get over it. OMG, people are so touchy about Claire!

It's because she's such a favorite... and kind of mysterious in a way. We still do not know a whole lot about her.

[notsolost42]

It's because she's such a favorite... and kind of mysterious in a way. We still do not know a whole lot about her.

I know, it was just my idea of satirical humor. Fans adore her character.

[Archangel-Player]

Is she dead? Or is she just hanging with her dad...I don't understand why she is with him....I thought she did not want to see him -- confused -- :confused: And, I don't understand why Christian told Locke that "Aaron was where he was supposed to be" when the psychic lady told Claire that she was not to allow anyone else to raise her baby -- she had to be the one to raise Aaron.....can anyone clear that up or have I again, missed a major point......help!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't think Clair is dead. IMO she doesn't have to be dead to be seen with Christin. Im not certin why alot of people think that. Id like to know. Not that it's wrong to think so. Everyone is intitled to their opion. That is the question the producers have said we should wounder. Not if she is alive but why sh eis with Christin andnot with Arran.

Christian told Locke "He is where he is supose to be. Not here" because like he said he is safe. If he would be anywhere other then with Sawyer something would happen that he would be in danger. If Clair would have taken Arran Kate wouldn't have gotten him to safety. Now Just because Arran is away from Claire right then doesn't mean he was meant to be raised by another. He simply needed to be away from Claire at that moment to be safe. It's a little unclear right now why exactly Arran had to be away from Clair. But there is a reason and it deals with his safety. Kinda like in Star Wars when the twins had to be hidden or else they would be found and raised twards the Dark side or killed.

[Archangel-Player]

Maybe you can read in this topic about it.

http://www.lost.com/forum/showthread.php?t=3224&highlight=claire+isn%27t+dead

and here another one that started the subject before.

http://www.lost.com/forum/showthread.php?t=3444&highlight=claire

the search is so easy to use you know.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tell me something. I know for fact that Christian is dead the producer cleard that up. But they class him as living dead. So if the dead can't hold the living how did he pick up Arran? That is why I belive something is in the guise of Christian and that it's not actualy him just like in spirtual beleafs a spirt can inhabit a body and know what the body knows. But in fact isn't the body's orignal soule. I think something is playing his body as a pupet. While the enity is in the body. The body lives.

[Turnip Queen]

She's totally alive...something else has happened to her to put her in that trance like state, but she is alive.
I'm still hoping she's alive too! We have no proof of her death yet! It's all very strange though, I'm dying to know what the hell is going on! Will she get in the helicopter like Desmond's vision?

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

She's totally alive...something else has happened to her to put her in that trance like state, but she is alive.

You know, Ort, I used to think Claire bit the dust, but after watching the rerun last night, not so sure anymore... but yes, she IS acting "out there", isn't she? Evidently, if she is NOT dead, then Christian had to have told her somethin' awfully special about Aaron because ordinarily, Claire would be frantic to get him back, right? hmmm....

[sirchin]

"they are coming to take me away haha! they are coming to take me away"!

Man! Hadn't heard that in a while! You are refering to that old song right?

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

Man! Hadn't heard that in a while! You are refering to that old song right?

NO! They're really coming to take him away...hee hee ho ho

[sirchin]

There's gonna be a lot going on the last episode! They may not even address,
Jacob, Claire, Christain, or the cabin. As far as answering any questions I mean. I kinda beleive they may show a visual though, something extremely shocking. There will be some revalations I'm sure. Something to keep us talking another FRIGGEN MONTHS!!!! Don'tcha love it!

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

There's gonna be a lot going on the last episode! They may not even address,
Jacob, Claire, Christain, or the cabin. As far as answering any questions I mean. I kinda beleive they may show a visual though, something extremely shocking. There will be some revalations I'm sure. Something to keep us talking another FRIGGEN MONTHS!!!! Don'tcha love it!

I DO! Because I'm going to miss this forum TERRIBLY if everyone decides to split for the summer! What will I do? They'll come and take ME away....

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

There's gonna be a lot going on the last episode! They may not even address,
Jacob, Claire, Christain, or the cabin. As far as answering any questions I mean. I kinda beleive they may show a visual though, something extremely shocking. There will be some revalations I'm sure. Something to keep us talking another FRIGGEN MONTHS!!!! Don'tcha love it!

Hey, Sirch! This a.m. I just thought of another BO...
Bo Derek!
and how about BO WO, the inarticulate dog....

[sirchin]

Hey, Sirch! This a.m. I just thought of another BO...
Bo Derek!
and how about BO WO, the inarticulate dog....

LOL! Your truly are my sweetheart.....

How bout Bo Diddly!

[ortrules]

You know, Ort, I used to think Claire bit the dust, but after watching the rerun last night, not so sure anymore... but yes, she IS acting "out there", isn't she? Evidently, if she is NOT dead, then Christian had to have told her somethin' awfully special about Aaron because ordinarily, Claire would be frantic to get him back, right? hmmm....

Right, and that's exactly what the producers have told us. They've said the question we should be asking is not whether Claire is dead, but what happened to her.

There is definitely something going on between Aaron, Claire, Christian, and the island - and for some reason that we don't know yet, it was necessary for Claire to leave Aaron behind. I always felt like the look on her face was that of euphoria or enlightenment, like maybe she's been revealed the secrets of the island.

[danielle222]

Maybe Miles has something to do with Claire. Maybe he has the ability to hynotize or put her under some kind of trance. I really don't want to believe she is dead.

[Archangel-Player]

She's totally alive...something else has happened to her to put her in that trance like state, but she is alive.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
That's what i meantioned before. I was thinking she is under some type of trance or drug. Perhaps the same serum that Eithan Gave her to make her want to give up Arran and have him cut out of her. I know Alex made her realize she was uder the influance. So perhaps soemone will slap her and she wakes up or hands them a hit of the **** sh ehas and they call it a night :-)

[gingergrant]

It's like when she says "I'm fine" and smiles, she is sort of thinking about maybe Aaron being someone/something that she never dreamed of? Like a superhuman or something. How would you look if someone told you that your child was the second coming? Stunned, sort of happy, bewildered?

[mahalo_dude]

It's like when she says "I'm fine" and smiles, she is sort of thinking about maybe Aaron being someone/something that she never dreamed of? Like a superhuman or something. How would you look if someone told you that your child was the second coming? Stunned, sort of happy, bewildered?

Exactly. She's been briefed on the whole island deal, so she knows Aaron will be okay and that she most likely will be too. Although she didn't pack a diaper bag for Sawyer to bring with him...:D

[Panda]

Panda, thanks for your input but I was making an inside joke to Ort. You see, Ort always plays my "Devils Advocate" when I start bouncing theories around. We have had a long running debate between ourselves about Claire. I was actually making a joke to Ort and it wasn't that I was making a statement to the thread. People come here to debate all the time and we, as Horace did, repeat ourselves quite often. It happen's. So what. Anyway, I apologize if you mistook what I said.

You don't need to apologize if I am the one that mistook what you said.
So I am sorry that I have interrupt your inside jokes and debates on the world wide web.

And of course people may repeat themselves if that is what they are living for. Fine. I won't make that mistake anymore to add links to similar topics.
If people would be really interested in what was already written about it, they would search for it themselves and continue in the existing topics. But as they don't it means that is not what they want to know about.
So it won't happen again. Sorry that I did mistook what you said.