Pierre Chang

[Dr Violence]

Hey Guys,
This is my first new thread, not sure if this has come up before but I myself have mentioned this theory.

Roussou said she was on a science team and that's how she got on the island right? Well she also mentioned that someone in her team lost an arm.
Also, the writers have also stated in podcasts that pierre chang(marvin candle or edgar halliwax etc) will feature in season 5 and we'll also get a flashback of roussou.

Now Marvin Candle is not only a scientist, he has one arm. So was he with roussou's science team? roussou is french and pierre is a french name.....

Thoughts guys?

[Jon]

and a member of the team named Montand lost his arm at some point.

Still, it's an interesting coincidence... maybe there's something more to it... :)

[notsolost42]

Hey Guys,
This is my first new thread, not sure if this has come up before but I myself have mentioned this theory.

Roussou said she was on a science team and that's how she got on the island right? Well she also mentioned that someone in her team lost an arm.
Also, the writers have also stated in podcasts that pierre chang(marvin candle or edgar halliwax etc) will feature in season 5 and we'll also get a flashback of roussou.

Now Marvin Candle is not only a scientist, he has one arm. So was he with roussou's science team? roussou is french and pierre is a french name.....

Thoughts guys?

No, afraid not. The other member of her science team who lost an arm had a different name. His name was Montand.

[boutte]

Well Candle has aliases already, why not one more?

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

No, afraid not. The other member of her science team who lost an arm had a different name. His name was Montand.

Good lateral thinking, Dr. Violence, but... FraidSo, NotSo's right! ;):D

[boutte]

Good lateral thinking, Dr. Violence, but... FraidSo, NotSo's right! ;):D
But whatdo we know about Montand? Could be an alias.

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

But whatdo we know about Montand? Could be an alias.

eh...I still think they're just toying with us with the one arm thing.

[Dr Violence]

Ah right can't believe i missed his name... but could be an alias i guess? would be cool.

[krakup]

Ah right can't believe i missed his name... but could be an alias i guess? would be cool.

Aye lad, tha knowws, thee's got a good'un there by't way lad.
Candle could be montand u think? hmmmmm

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

Aye lad, tha knowws, thee's got a good'un there by't way lad.
Candle could be montand u think? hmmmmm

Krakup, you Aussie, you... I'll always love your accent, man! :cool:

[Dr Violence]

Think he's doing a northern english accent cos i live in manchester (home of charlie of course) but im actually from london.

[beachblinkette]

Anyone with the initials P.C. could be a "politically correct" character.....If you don't want to know about Montand don't read the spoilers, what ever you do!!:D

[krakup]

Think he's doing a northern english accent cos i live in manchester (home of charlie of course) but im actually from london.

i know u r a southerner Dr, but u have a yorkshire connection? which is why i said u have a good'un :)

[boutte]

eh...I still think they're just toying with us with the one arm thing.
Oh they wouldn't do that! Would they?

[navyguy]

Unfortunately Montand and Pierre Chang are not the same. The character of Montand is to be played by Actor Marc Menard, a man who looks like he is a chiseled out underwear model.