PDA

View Full Version : Sayid's Girl Nadia- Timeline Inconsistency


meesterperfect
02-12-2008, 02:28 PM
Hey.
One thing I love about Lost is putting together a timeline connecting all the survivers connections and actions right up until the time of the crash.
They all seem to make perfect sense, except for Nadia.
We know she escaped from Iraq in 1997, thats a fact.
But Charlie saw her in England before Driveshaft got famous while singing on the street, which according to Desmonds timeline was in 1996.
Its possible this encounter may have happened in 97 which does make it a legit occurance. What year did Driveshaft get BIG?
Now the Locke timeline is a little tricky also.
Locke encountered Nadia while inspecting her new home at the same time he was dating Helen (Yes,Peg Bundy).
Could that have been after 1997?
We know Locke was paralyzed in 2000. Before that he was a recluse livng on disability in 1999, 2000 ?
Before that I thought he lived at the pot farm which would have been around 98.
Perhaps Locke lived at the commune before he dated Helen. That is a big question. Anybody know? When was Locke at the pot farm? Dating Helen?
Anyway, it seems Nadia was doing an awful lot in 97 and 98. Escaping Iraq, living in England, buying a house in California..........Theories? Facts? Opinions?
Thanks.

navyguy
02-12-2008, 05:22 PM
Hey.
One thing I love about Lost is putting together a timeline connecting all the survivers connections and actions right up until the time of the crash.
They all seem to make perfect sense, except for Nadia.
We know she escaped from Iraq in 1997, thats a fact.
But Charlie saw her in England before Driveshaft got famous while singing on the street, which according to Desmonds timeline was in 1996.
Its possible this encounter may have happened in 97 which does make it a legit occurance. What year did Driveshaft get BIG?
Now the Locke timeline is a little tricky also.
Locke encountered Nadia while inspecting her new home at the same time he was dating Helen (Yes,Peg Bundy).
Could that have been after 1997?
We know Locke was paralyzed in 2000. Before that he was a recluse livng on disability in 1999, 2000 ?
Before that I thought he lived at the pot farm which would have been around 98.
Perhaps Locke lived at the commune before he dated Helen. That is a big question. Anybody know? When was Locke at the pot farm? Dating Helen?
Anyway, it seems Nadia was doing an awful lot in 97 and 98. Escaping Iraq, living in England, buying a house in California..........Theories? Facts? Opinions?
Thanks.

Dude the pot farm had to be late 70's early 80's. The cop that used Locke at the farm is the same US marshall that captured kate in australia.

Dzbabykel
02-12-2008, 05:25 PM
Was it the same guy?? I had never noticed that before. And as for Helen, that I believe was in between 97 and 2000 because they didn't date ALL that long. He met Helen after meeting his father and she left him because he was so consumed with following him. But yah you may be right about Nadia...maybe it was a mistake? Haha I think we forget those writers at Lost aren't really Gods hahaha although they are pretty damn close!

bunnydixon
02-12-2008, 05:34 PM
Hey.
One thing I love about Lost is putting together a timeline connecting all the survivers connections and actions right up until the time of the crash.
They all seem to make perfect sense, except for Nadia.
We know she escaped from Iraq in 1997, thats a fact.
But Charlie saw her in England before Driveshaft got famous while singing on the street, which according to Desmonds timeline was in 1996.
Its possible this encounter may have happened in 97 which does make it a legit occurance. What year did Driveshaft get BIG?
Now the Locke timeline is a little tricky also.
Locke encountered Nadia while inspecting her new home at the same time he was dating Helen (Yes,Peg Bundy).
Could that have been after 1997?
We know Locke was paralyzed in 2000. Before that he was a recluse livng on disability in 1999, 2000 ?
Before that I thought he lived at the pot farm which would have been around 98.
Perhaps Locke lived at the commune before he dated Helen. That is a big question. Anybody know? When was Locke at the pot farm? Dating Helen?
Anyway, it seems Nadia was doing an awful lot in 97 and 98. Escaping Iraq, living in England, buying a house in California..........Theories? Facts? Opinions?
Thanks.

http://www.lostpedia.com/wiki/Pre-crash_timeline

this should help you with dates for all these :D

TuesdaySmith
02-12-2008, 06:36 PM
Dude the pot farm had to be late 70's early 80's. The cop that used Locke at the farm is the same US marshall that captured kate in australia.

The cop that used Locke was Eddie Colburn and the US Marshal was Edward Mars.

KarmaKate
02-12-2008, 07:02 PM
the police officer kate was married to mal from firefly. I don't think tom is the the farmer.

meesterperfect
02-12-2008, 07:56 PM
http://www.lostpedia.com/wiki/Pre-crash_timeline

this should help you with dates for all these :D

Ok Bunny, nice link.
It doesn't say when Locke gave away his kidney, but it does say his mother was in the mental hospital in 1992 which means he gave away his kidney AFTER 92.
Possibly/probably 1993.
He was at the commune in 1994/95 but then he had to leave.
It says late 90's (probably around 97-98) his father staged his death, which was the same time he was dating Helen and inspected Nadia's new home.
Ok that makes sense.
So Nadia left Iraq, lived in Manchester, England for a short time( saw Charlie), then somehow came up with the money to buy a house in California in late 97 or 98.
Mystery solved? But I still say she was a busy girl.