Ok this is a stupid Question

[rip-charlie]

I was at work yesterday and I was thinking if the island goes back in time, ( remember Ben Moved it) can people come back from the dead? On the island if they died on the island? The more i think about it it sounds stupid because the bodys are rotting I don't know just thought it was something to think about. sorry

[krakup]

I was at work yesterday and I was thinking if the island goes back in time, ( remember Ben Moved it) can people come back from the dead? On the island if they died on the island? The more i think about it it sounds stupid because the bodys are rotting I don't know just thought it was something to think about. sorry

not stupid, exactly what i want to have settled. i'm guessing , as others have time is moving. very slowly on the island

[Monkey-Hands]

I was at work yesterday and I was thinking if the island goes back in time, ( remember Ben Moved it) can people come back from the dead? On the island if they died on the island? The more i think about it it sounds stupid because the bodys are rotting I don't know just thought it was something to think about. sorry

That is very well possible. Because if you watch one of the new promo trailers you'll get a short glimpse of Ethan pointing a gun at Locke. And as we all now, Charlie shot Ethan, but now he's back. So I think it is possible.

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

That is very well possible. Because if you watch one of the new promo trailers you'll get a short glimpse of Ethan pointing a gun at Locke. And as we all now, Charlie shot Ethan, but now he's back. So I think it is possible.

Are you sure that's Ethan? Really? Oh, because I was about to say they don't show anyone who's assumed to be dead in the promos. That's interesting. hmmm. I think the only thing we can be sure of, though, is that they will spend the entire season just trying to return and possibly the very last show of Season 5 will be their arrival back to the island. Just like last season, it took them 16 epi's to walk less than a mile. HA!!

[rip-charlie]

That is very well possible. Because if you watch one of the new promo trailers you'll get a short glimpse of Ethan pointing a gun at Locke. And as we all now, Charlie shot Ethan, but now he's back. So I think it is possible.

Well there is something about the island we know that I mean it made Locke able to walk again and took rose's Cancer way ( well atleast we think) I don't know i was at work and this thought poped in my head and it was hard to shake it. And not knowing the Claire is dead or alive and Then there is Jin I'm not sure i just can't wait till it comes back on. I'm going to work now 9 hours of thinking coming up!!! lol I'll be on tonight or in the morning with new thought Sorry for all of you guys! lol have a great day talk with you later.

[Monkey-Hands]

Are you sure that's Ethan? Really? Oh, because I was about to say they don't show anyone who's assumed to be dead in the promos. That's interesting. hmmm. I think the only thing we can be sure of, though, is that they will spend the entire season just trying to return and possibly the very last show of Season 5 will be their arrival back to the island. Just like last season, it took them 16 epi's to walk less than a mile. HA!!

Yep, look at the pics:

http://e.imagehost.org/0949/ethan.jpg
http://e.imagehost.org/0682/cap2.png

What I'm asking myslef now is, if the dead are back alive, do they know they have been killed or is it like rewinding a tape? Everything back to the start.

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

Well there is something about the island we know that I mean it made Locke able to walk again and took rose's Cancer way ( well atleast we think) I don't know i was at work and this thought poped in my head and it was hard to shake it. And not knowing the Claire is dead or alive and Then there is Jin I'm not sure i just can't wait till it comes back on. I'm going to work now 9 hours of thinking coming up!!! lol I'll be on tonight or in the morning with new thought Sorry for all of you guys! lol have a great day talk with you later.

Oh, poop! You're gone. I wanted to talk to you little charlie!
Anyway, as for Jin, I do think he's alive and is the one they say floated up to the island on a box. But that's all I heard.
(Charlie, when you have time, go to the PB thread sometime and talk to me!)

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

Yep, look at the pics:

http://e.imagehost.org/0949/ethan.jpg
http://e.imagehost.org/0682/cap2.png

WHOA !! AND DOUBLE WHOA!!!!
What on not earth is going on there!!??? This is going to get just too weird, I'm afraid...

[Monkey-Hands]

WHOA !! AND DOUBLE WHOA!!!!
What on not earth is going on there!!??? This is going to get just too weird, I'm afraid...

Hell yeah!

[krakup]

lol great screen caps mhand, i cant wait to find out

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

Hell yeah!

and what's going to happen if some of them are locked in to other's time warps? I mean, for example, I am convinced that when they went around the loop a diff time, Juliet and Ben definitely had a relationship... would everyone's timing be all screwed up now? And when the O6 arrive back, will the LOSTies on the island NOT RECOGNIZE THEM???

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

And what about 3.5 yr old Aaron? What's Claire going to think about him calling Kate Mommy if she's there? too confusing...

[Monkey-Hands]

And when the O6 arrive back, will the LOSTies on the island NOT RECOGNIZE THEM???

Hmmm, that would be weird, cause Locke went back in time with the island too, and does remember them. Oh man, this is crazy. Can somebody move the island again please, to send me to the future so I can already watch the new season?
Of course I would then find a way back to tell you everything. ;):cool:

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

Hmmm, that would be weird, cause Locke went back in time with the island too, and does remember them. Oh man, this is crazy. Can somebody move the island again please, to send me to the future so I can already watch the new season?
Of course I would then find a way back to tell you everything. ;):cool:

Yeah, there's an awful lot happening at once. I just hope people don't lose heart and stop watching or that all the confusion will deter new viewers. It's such a magnificent show, it shouldn't ever be dismissed just because it's hard to figure out.
I want some pizza now.

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

Monkey, do you have any theories about Charlotte? I don't think she's a time lord (if that's really what some of these people are, as assumed by those in the Seasons threads) because she's too uncertain about who she is. Last thing she said, I think, was something like wanting to find out where she was born.

[Monkey-Hands]

Yeah, there's an awful lot happening at once. I just hope people don't lose heart and stop watching or that all the confusion will deter new viewers. It's such a magnificent show, it shouldn't ever be dismissed just because it's hard to figure out.
I want some pizza now.

IMO this is the best show EVER made!!
But also M.A.S.K., Transformers, Smallville, Prison Break, MacGuyver and Gilmore Girls. :D

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

IMO this is the best show EVER made!!
But also M.A.S.K., Transformers, Smallville, Prison Break, MacGuyver and Gilmore Girls. :D

:eek: Gilmore Girls?!?!:eek: LOLOLOLOL

[Monkey-Hands]

:eek: Gilmore Girls?!?!:eek: LOLOLOLOL

GG is hella funny, trust me! When my GF started watching it I was like "Meh, what is this crap?", but it's a really funny show.

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

GG is hella funny, trust me! When my GF started watching it I was like "Meh, what is this crap?", but it's a really funny show.

betcha can't out-talk her, though... what do you think? like 500 words per minute? hahaha

[Monkey-Hands]

betcha can't out-talk her, though... what do you think? like 500 words per minute? hahaha

Haha, yeah! They talk pretty fast. I can really recommend it.

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

Haha, yeah! They talk pretty fast. I can really recommend it.

Monkey, since this is the "stupid question" thread, I want to ask you something. Is LOST dubbed in German over there or is English a widely spoken language?

[Monkey-Hands]

Monkey, do you have any theories about Charlotte? I don't think she's a time lord (if that's really what some of these people are, as assumed by those in the Seasons threads) because she's too uncertain about who she is. Last thing she said, I think, was something like wanting to find out where she was born.

Hmmm, nothing really. What I'm thinking of if she really was born on the island.
Or that maybe "beein born" has another meaning. Like with Locke, cause I think you can say that Locke was kind of reborn when he came to the island. You know what I mean?

But maybe she's Ben's little Girlfriend?! Now THAT would be crazy.

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

Hmmm, nothing really. What I'm thinking of if she really was born on the island.
Or that maybe "beein born" has another meaning. Like with Locke, cause I think you can say that Locke was kind of reborn when he came to the island. You know what I mean?

But maybe she's Ben's little Girlfriend?! Now THAT would be crazy.

ok, wanna hear what I'm thinking? MAYBE... Despite the age not adding up, remember the time warps could mess with that... Maybe Charlotte will turn out to be Ben and Annie's child. Why? Because Ben was pre-occupied with the issue of pregnant women not carrying to term and dying more than what Tom and Richard deemed more important details of the island, and because it seems a highly unusual thing for a 20 something yr old male to do, stealing and raising a baby as his own unless it was to console himself on the loss of possibly his OWN wife/baby, and because Ben knew all about that box with the 15 yr old saltine crackers inside ( I just can't get past that one!) and that possibly he had whisked Annie off in that direction to leave the island via the donkey wheel room before she and baby would die. Add to that, just think about Ben's life. First he loses his mother and feels guilt over that (his father blaming him), then he loses the woman he loves (or girl, however Annie figures into this), then he loses his Alex - again with guilt... then he shoots Charlotte, although obviously didn't kill her! WHat a kick in the pants it would be if she turned out to be his daughter! Just some thoughts...

[R.I.P.Charlie]

how old is charlette? Late twenties? ben is what in his forties?

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

how old is charlette? Late twenties? ben is what in his forties?

I know. The 15 yr thing doesn't add up. By normal timelines, she'd be about Alex's age or maybe a little older. Who knows... that's why I was only speculating. Well, that plus the fact that I love Ben so much and would like to see him have some semblance of a life where he loved and was loved by a "family" of a sort, especially since his dad was such a bastard.

[Unbridled Pageantry]

What if Charlotte were another daughter of Charles Widmore. They both have a fascination with the island, both have money (Charlotte bought her way into the archeological dig, it wasn't hers), and was reading the paper on the 815 crash. Maybe she's Widmore's daughter from the island and he hid her from Penelope. Widmore could have been sending Charlotte to spots like the dig for himself.
Well, if I'm gonna think this way I might as well throw this one out there. Naomi is the inter-racial bastard love child of Widmore and Ms. Klugh. That was just a joke, but thinking of it now...

[Monkey-Hands]

Monkey, since this is the "stupid question" thread, I want to ask you something. Is LOST dubbed in German over there or is English a widely spoken language?

Yep, Lost is dubbed over here. Although english is very common in the daily routine. Like in food, music etc.

[LostLate]

how old is charlette? Late twenties? ben is what in his forties?

And Ben supposedly only learned of Charlotte from Michael being on the freighter...

[rip-charlie]

IMO this is the best show EVER made!!
But also M.A.S.K., Transformers, Smallville, Prison Break, MacGuyver and Gilmore Girls. :D

Hey MOnkey hands your into PB? well we should talk lol I'm rip-charlie and i'm love PB remember I'm lil rip-charlie!! lol

[Monkey-Hands]

Hey MOnkey hands your into PB? well we should talk lol I'm rip-charlie and i'm love PB remember I'm lil rip-charlie!! lol

Yeah, PB is awesome. Unfortunately I only have seen season 1 and like the half of season 2. Season 3 hasn't even started yet over here. :(:mad:

[rip-charlie]

Yeah, PB is awesome. Unfortunately I only have seen season 1 and like the half of season 2. Season 3 hasn't even started yet over here. :(:mad:

WHAT????? Oh my we are into season 4 and it will blow your mind!!!! all the changes that have happened. When does your season 3 start? Because Season 3 was not all that great, but it was good. Oh wow i can't wait for next week

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

WHAT????? Oh my we are into season 4 and it will blow your mind!!!! all the changes that have happened. When does your season 3 start? Because Season 3 was not all that great, but it was good. Oh wow i can't wait for next week

Agree, charlie! Monkey, you've GOT to keep watching!
Like LOST, the entire mood/environment/location/feeling changes depending upon where they are for most of the season. 3 was dark, disturbing, but fascinating still, and you're gonna be awed by how the charactors evolve!
And just wait til you meet psycho-bi***! Even T-Bag would cower from her!
There's a PB thread somewhere we should really keep PB chat in instead of here, so if anyone can find it, bring it up!:)

[Monkey-Hands]

WHAT????? Oh my we are into season 4 and it will blow your mind!!!! all the changes that have happened. When does your season 3 start? Because Season 3 was not all that great, but it was good. Oh wow i can't wait for next week

There's no exact date set yet. But it won't start until next year. :(
I want to buy season 1 & 2 on DVD soon.

[LostLate]

There's no exact date set yet. But it won't start until next year. :(
I want to buy season 1 & 2 on DVD soon.

What are you waiting for MH? Season 4 is coming out here on DVD on Tuesday.

Are you sure you're in Germany and not on the island? Time seems to be moving slower for you there LOL.

[gingergrant]

People coming back from the dead...

Jack's dad not being in the coffin anymore.
Charlie, saying that he is dead and not dead now..(or something like that)
Who was it on the boat that washed up on shore and then was on the boat?

not remembering things...
Charlotte not remembering what Daniel seems to think she should remember
Daniel taking test for memory

There is probably more, but I can't remember! Ha!

[LostLate]

People coming back from the dead...

Jack's dad not being in the coffin anymore.
Charlie, saying that he is dead and not dead now..(or something like that)
Who was it on the boat that washed up on shore and then was on the boat?

not remembering things...
Charlotte not remembering what Daniel seems to think she should remember
Daniel taking test for memory

There is probably more, but I can't remember! Ha!

Ginger - Charlie said, "I am dead...but I'm also here."
The doctor from the freighter washed up on the shore, but the boat said he was fine.

I often don't remember too, but I think that's how it went down.

[gingergrant]

thanks LostLate

[Here'sLOCKEing at you,Kid]

GINGER! HI! Come to the barma if you can

[konbon]

Do you even watch lost i mean anybody who ever watches lost knows that anybody who is dead really isnt dead