Red head in Ben's class = Charlotte?

[LissaMarie]

In episode 20 "The Man Behind the Curtain" they show a scene in Ben's school classroom (it is at 13:47). I don't believe that Charlotte is Annie but I'm wondering if she could have been a classmate. Thoughts?

[Jeremy]

I don't know. I would have thought that Ben has about 10-15 years on Charlotte, but I'm not familiar with any D.O.B's on the show aside from the year Locke was born.

[LissaMarie]

I agree about the age difference but I thought maybe they had a single classroom for all grades, ala "Little House on The Prarie". It's just frustrating because now we know that Charlotte was a Dharma kid and obviously Ben was too.

[Unbridled Pageantry]

we know that Charlotte was a Dharma kid and obviously Ben was too.

I think I saw a bumper sticker on Roger Linus' VW that said PROUD PARENT OF A DHARMA VOCATIONAL GRAD

I also want to see if there's any asian Mile's looking children in that class.

[gingergrant]

I think I saw a bumper sticker on Roger Linus' VW that said PROUD PARENT OF A DHARMA VOCATIONAL GRAD

.

LOL! I want one! Now! or at least one that says
My child can commune with the island and threw all the other Dharma students in a pit!

[LissaMarie]

LOL, Ginger! Who wouldn't be proud!

[Peterislost]

in the episode man behind the curtain, the scene where young ben is in the classroom and the hostiles attack, there is a supposed glimpse of Lafleur aka Sawyer outside the window...

http://lostpedia.wikia.com/wiki/The_Man_Behind_the_Curtain/Theories

That link is from lostpedia and at the bottom it talks about the scene i am describing..the question is if that is meant to be Lafleur then is this proof that there is one timeline and the losties travelling bk in time is what always happened?

[Desi420]

in the episode man behind the curtain, the scene where young ben is in the classroom and the hostiles attack, there is a supposed glimpse of Lafleur aka Sawyer outside the window...

http://lostpedia.wikia.com/wiki/The_Man_Behind_the_Curtain/Theories

That link is from lostpedia and at the bottom it talks about the scene i am describing..the question is if that is meant to be Lafleur then is this proof that there is one timeline and the losties travelling bk in time is what always happened?
Having read that, and rewatching on my HD flat screen plasma, with a zoom button on my DVD player, it is not Josh Holloway. Though we don't see many long haired blond guys in Dharma that we know of.

Maybe they used a double so to look enough like Sawyer, but not Sawyer, if you get my drift.

I for one believe in the single timeline theroy myself.

[Desi420]

I think I saw a bumper sticker on Roger Linus' VW that said PROUD PARENT OF A DHARMA VOCATIONAL GRAD

I also want to see if there's any asian Mile's looking children in that class.
There wouldnt be seeing that is an earlier memory of Ben's which is a while before the Incident and Miles is only a few months old at that time.

[LissaMarie]

Wow, I had forgotten about this post! I think the little redhead actually did turn out to be Charlotte, right? Hey! I guess it's not always a waste of time to pick every scene apart. All hail the pause button!! :D

[rock-lobster]

in the episode man behind the curtain, the scene where young ben is in the classroom and the hostiles attack, there is a supposed glimpse of Lafleur aka Sawyer outside the window...

http://lostpedia.wikia.com/wiki/The_Man_Behind_the_Curtain/Theories

That link is from lostpedia and at the bottom it talks about the scene i am describing..the question is if that is meant to be Lafleur then is this proof that there is one timeline and the losties travelling bk in time is what always happened?

Well I don't think it's LaFleur because of the timing. Ben told Sayid in 1977 that he went to see Richard 4 years ago= 1973, before any of them came to DHARMA.

and the scene in the classroom takes place before Ben sees Richard for the first time, so logically it can't be LaFleur.

[Desi420]

Well I don't think it's LaFleur because of the timing. Ben told Sayid in 1977 that he went to see Richard 4 years ago= 1973, before any of them came to DHARMA.

and the scene in the classroom takes place before Ben sees Richard for the first time, so logically it can't be LaFleur.
Good call!!!

[Peterislost]

that is a good call rock-lobster, i was merely bringing up the point because i saw it on lostpedia and it intrigued me! I never thought it was josh holoway but would have been kinda cool if it was a long haired guy meant to look like lafleur...but like u say the whole sayid and ben thing would contradict this.

It makes me wonder if there are any other instances where our time travelling losties were seen in 1977 before season 5, and they were simply subtly blended in? Mind u i cant think of any situations where they would ave appaeared of the top of my head.