PDA

View Full Version : Theory based on Spoiler: Claire Dies


TheFlash
02-15-2008, 05:56 PM
I'm a regular reader, but first time poster.

Here's a theory I've come up with based on the SPOILER (don't read if you don't like spoilers) below. Sorry if it's been mentioned before, but I didn't see it.

So in Episode 4, if the spoiler is true, Kate is raising Aaron. The spoiler says Kate has "another special person in her life already. Someone who was on the plane, but didn't have a ticket." So Aaron was in the womb, so he was on the plane but didn't have a ticket. Easy enough.

Go back to the Season 3's Finale. Kate says to Jack, "He'll be wondering where I am." So we all have assumed it's a lover, but why couldn't "he" be a son, or Aaron.

I've also read that another major character will die in Season 4. Why not Claire?

Go back to Season 3's Finale again. The coffin seems to be pretty short. Claire is short. I know everyone claims it is a man according to the newspaper clip, but we can't be 100% sure at this point. And why would Kate react so harshly when Jack asked if she went to see the body? Maybe Claire and Kate had a falling out, or maybe Kate is just protective of her new "son," which was really Claire's.

Just a theory. Go ahead and start tearing it apart.

------------------
SPOILER:
SEASON 4 EPISODE 4 EGGTOWN - KATE FLASHFORWARD
Locke is holding Ben prisoner in the basement of one of the houses of Otherville. Ben refuses to tell who his mole on the freighter is or why these people are looking for the island. Kate and Claire share a house and chat about babies. Locke won’t tell Kate where Miles in imprisoned, but she then tricks Hurley into revealing it is the boathouse. When she talks to Miles he says he will only answer her questions if she can get him a meeting with Ben. On Kate’s request, Sawyer lures Locke away. Kate brings the two prisoners together and Ben affirms that he knows who Miles is, and why he is there. Miles then asks for 3 million dollars in return for telling “everyone” that Ben is already dead. He promises to take care of his partner Charlotte who is also aware of Ben’s whereabouts. Ben agrees and gives him a week. Miles then answers Kate’s questions: yes, the freighters know about her criminal record. When Locke finally returns, he bans Kate from his team. Kate has one more night of sex with Sawyer but they end it with a serious row about her possibly being pregnant. Sawyer doesn't take the whole baby thing well. Although she denies it, they break up.
FF Jack and Kate have some extremely touching moments but it doesn't end well. Kate is arrested for the murder of her stepfather. When she steps out of a Town Car in front of the courthouse, there are dozens of camera/news reporters snapping pictures and trying to get an interview. One person even yels “MURDERER” at her. are also armed L.A. police and Sheriff's uniforms about. Inside, she is denied bail. Her lawyer says he wants to sway the jury by bringing Kate’s son in the courtroom. Kate doesn’t want that. Instead, the lawyer then brings Jack to the witness stand. Jack lies to the jury and tells that Kate was a heroine, that she saved the Oceanic Six on her own. The prosecutor asks him if he loves Kate, he says he doesn’t anymore. Afterwards, the lawyer brings in Kate’s mom, who apparently is dying of cancer and is feeling remorse for what has happened between them in the past. Kate’s mom refuses to take the witness stand a Kate makes a deal for ten years probation. When she leaves the court she’s met by a clean-shaven, leather-jacket wearing Jack, who steps away from an older, brown pickup truck. There’s some awkwardness, but there are also some smiles. Kate shows romantic interest in future Jack, but it turns out there's another special person in her life already. Someone who was on the plane, but didn't have a ticket. Jack doesn’t want to come with her, because of her son. Eventually, Jack helps Kate get into a yellow taxi cab, and watches as it drives away. Kate goes home and there cuddles a 3 or 4 year-old Aaron, whom she is raising.

bunnydixon
02-15-2008, 07:17 PM
i havent read it as i cant stand spoilers but putting part of the spoiler in the title - well, doesnt give peeps the chance to keep away from it really!!!! so thanks! ;)

thelawgiver
02-15-2008, 07:27 PM
It could possibly be Claire in the coffin, but doubtful. She had no family, but I doubt that Jack would say he was not her friend (or family)

thelawgiver
02-15-2008, 07:28 PM
Also, there is the obit problem which refers to a man from New York with a teenage son.

Dzbabykel
02-15-2008, 07:44 PM
Pleeeease don't post spoilers in the main discussions haha I don't want to know!! :)

eqkedri
02-16-2008, 07:29 AM
The article said a man from New York was dead. Can't be Claire.

UnknownPoster
02-16-2008, 09:09 AM
Claire's aunt was hown pretty prominently. I cannot remember her dying unless it happened while they were on the island. Or Christian murdered her
________
Falcon (North America) (http://www.ford-wiki.com/wiki/Ford_Falcon_(North_America))

stevenharvey11
02-16-2008, 06:32 PM
It could possibly be Claire in the coffin, but doubtful. She had no family, but I doubt that Jack would say he was not her friend (or family)


Actually, she does have family. Jack is her half-brother. I just wonder if they ever find out.
________
Cat Exercise Wheel (http://www.catwheelcompany.com/)

az-phil
02-16-2008, 06:44 PM
What's with the title of your Post?

I'm not a fan of spoilers, and putting part of the spoiler in your title is pretty reckless don't ya think... :mad:

I'm not reading this thread, but I had to point this out with the hope you will use a little more common sense next time. I don't know this forum well yet, but I'm sure there is a proper place for Spoiler discussions.

http://www.subcortex.com/ChimpNoEvil.jpg
LA LA LA LA LA

youalleverybody
02-16-2008, 07:53 PM
I agree, no spoilers hre please :)
Also, I saw "Ben" on The View last week, he said that someone theat we have gotten to know 'fairly well' wont make it through the season, now that we have all read the subject of this thread, I guess it could be Clair, who else???.....

Rain13
02-16-2008, 08:55 PM
Where did you get that spoiler?

Ezekiel 25:17
02-16-2008, 09:23 PM
dude, look, its another crazy person putting up fake spoilers, idiot! When are people going to learn, First off Spoilers belong in the SPOILER section and second, why do u people bother posting fake 1's anyway, at least put somthing good like, Charlie returns from the "afterlife" lol .:eek:

jacksnurse
02-16-2008, 10:06 PM
u go ez......put em in their place..LOL

LostFreak21
02-16-2008, 10:08 PM
confucius say- He who posts spoilers will be followed by black smoke.

youalleverybody
02-16-2008, 11:50 PM
ok, let's go easy here, it was their first post, not again, right?.....(with the spoilers I mean)