dont know whos seen this but wow check it out

[vanni11]

http://www.timelooptheory.com/the_timeline.htm

[Dzbabykel]

Hmm interesting, thanks :)

[Lost in VA]

I totally buy into this theory. But I think Desmond is the key to things changing to keep all our Losties from dying.

[bunnydixon]

stopped reading when it went on about ben being born in 1970 - we know thats incorrect.

[lostlindy]

you need to read to the very end. It tells you who's name Jack saw in the paper. :eek: I must admit that's a pretty good theory

[bunnydixon]

i think it just lost all believeability for me over that LOL!

[lostlindy]

think about it, that could why Locke can walk, Rose doesn't have cancer and Mikhial never stays dead! ;)

[TSOL1]

Why would sawyer die early.. in this theory wouldnt he have to live atleast until the plane crashes? Thats how I am understanding this anyway.

[TSOL1]

i think it just lost all believeability for me over that LOL!

Yeah, I dont believe this either. It helps to explain some things, but at the same time contradicts itself. But it was creative. :)

[bunnydixon]

yeah but the fact that it has bens DOB so wrong - suggests it would knock the rest of their theory out of alignment.

i mean, the time loop thing makes sense in some way but i dont agree with the intricate details - it also contradicts itself in a few ways too.

[bunnydixon]

Yeah, I dont believe this either. It helps to explain some things, but at the same time contradicts itself. But it was creative. :)


lol - it does doesnt it!

[Dzbabykel]

I must admit its a very good, and well thought out theory...I especially like where it explained when Juliet was looking at the 25 year old woman's womb and saw that it was comparable to a 70 year old woman's. However, there also seem to be a lot of holes in the theory. There's no way Ben was born in 1980, haha that would make him only 28 years old! And some of the things he talks about with Rousseau are false too, he says her crew died from the illness but if you remember, she actually had killed them all because she THOUGHT they were sick. But it was def a good read :)

[lostlindy]

stopped reading when it went on about ben being born in 1970 - we know thats incorrect.

when was Ben supposidly born? because the seen showing him be born is definatly late 60's , early 70's. trust me I know, I've "been there" LOL :D

[bunnydixon]

i think its around 1963 - early 60s anyway. he arrives at the island in the early 70s.

[lostlindy]

when Hurley gets Rogers van running the 3 dog night song Shambala starts playing and that was released in 1974 so that means Ben had to be in his 20's when he gassed his father wich puts him being born in the 50's. but when they show him being born it's 60's-70's. and he still looks the same now as he did then. oh wow wait a minute I think I just really confused myself. does it work for you? LOL:D:confused:

[bunnydixon]

LOL!

I am always confused!

i think when ben killed his father it was the mid to late 80s and the radio station was just playing ol' toons!

[Dzbabykel]

when Hurley gets Rogers van running the 3 dog night song Shambala starts playing and that was released in 1974 so that means Ben had to be in his 20's when he gassed his father wich puts him being born in the 50's. but when they show him being born it's 60's-70's. and he still looks the same now as he did then. oh wow wait a minute I think I just really confused myself. does it work for you? LOL:D:confused:

Yeah but the theory posted says his mother gave birth in 1980? That wouldn't make sense at all

[lostlindy]

in 1980 shortly after his mothers death' he and his father went to the island

[bunnydixon]

but he was around 10 years old when he went to the island? i thought the website said that he was born 1970 but that would make him only about 18 when he kidnaps alex and 'becomes' her father.

the theory is there but the fine details just need a little tweak.

[lostlindy]

LOL!

I am always confused!

i think when ben killed his father it was the mid to late 80s and the radio station was just playing ol' toons!

no, the song was playing when hurly started the van. had to be an 8 track. see where I'm going with this? I think[?] I do :confused::D

[Ezekiel 25:17]

Wait, dudes, wait!!!!!!! Assuming this is correct, you can go back in time before any further injuries this means that the losties went back in time 4 years? Because Locke has been paralyzed for 4 years right? That would make sense, but that disproves this whole theory because, Claire still had her child at a reasonable time and the sox still won the series like 2 months later, so time didn't really change did it? If thats true, than this whole thing is wrong.

[bunnydixon]

oh right - my bad!

could it not just be an old album he was playing at the time though?

[lostlindy]

in a van?
:confused:

[Robo42]

Also with Locke, he gains full use of his legs after the crashh , but then starts to lose it again when he finds the Hatch and Boone gets killed. It's also intersesting how Jacks wife had a miraculous cure of her paralysis.

[bunnydixon]

would it not have a player of some kind? not cds obviously but tapes maybe?

however, even if it was real time and he killed his father in 1974 - that only further proves he could not have been born in 1970!!

[lostlindy]

see why I said I was confusing myself?? LOL

[Dzbabykel]

Yah and it was after Desmond talked to Jack at the stadium him telling him not to lose faith....and interstingly enough Locke started losing loss of his legs when he was losing faith about the hatch.

[bunnydixon]

i think i am going to have a scanners moment....

[King_Nate]

its all rite here,.... http://www.lostpedia.com/wiki/Timeline



everything u need 2 know..up to date too

[bunnydixon]

yep, yep - i am gonna

stand back everyone.......


*pop*

[UnknownPoster]

Maybe I am taking this too literally, but if Sawyer dies on a certain day or time, shouldn't the other 5 die around the same moment since they all dies in the same crash?

BTW the thoery says Ben is born in 1970 and comes to the island in 1980 which makes sense.
________
VAPORIZER REVIEW (http://vaporizers.tv/)

[lostlindy]

would it not have a player of some kind? not cds obviously but tapes maybe?

however, even if it was real time and he killed his father in 1974 - that only further proves he could not have been born in 1970!!

he didn't kill his father in 1980. that's somewhere around the time ben and his father came to the island

[UnknownPoster]

I am not sure I am totally 100% on board with this theory, but i do think there is something to this time loop stuff.

I think this is why Dan cries but doesn't know why - he has gone thru this before. I think it is also how Ben knows some of the stuff he knows.

Somehow I think the last scene of the finale is going to be that scene from S3 that showed each of them getting on the plane. some of the characters seem to acknowledge each other.
________
HENRY FORD CENTENNIAL LIBRARY (http://www.ford-wiki.com/wiki/Henry_Ford_Centennial_Library)

[Ezekiel 25:17]

yeah unknown, ur not the only one who thinks this is the way it might turn out. I always get the feeling like they have all been on the island before and didn't know it or somthing, in their subconsceince, i don't know, i think it may be somthing like that, 2nd time around though i really think so.

[bunnydixon]

perhaps it some kind of reincarnation thing?

[Trevor]

Despite minor miscalculations with dates it explains everything, Jacob, the black smoke, why Richard doesn't age, and why all the pregnant women die on the island.

[BrothaDezzy]

This whole thing is just made up. I dont buy this at all. I mean it is just a theory after all. Some parts contridict other parts and parts from the show. It was pretty much a well thought out story. I would only believe something like that if it was from a producer or a writer from the show.

[bunnydixon]

yeah the basis is there but they havent taken into account certain facts that dont gel exactly.

[Lost in VA]

We dont know for sure all we can do is theorize, but the writers know and eadch week they give us another piece of the puzzle.

[beachblinkette]

Thanks, Vanni, for the time theory website. I really like that I could understand some of it and that it appeared to explain the anomalies on the island. I'll keep watching my favorite show because of the characters. There are always some surprises in this life that we never quite expect, aren't there?:)

[Dzbabykel]

Side note...Ez I love the new avatar! :)

[KarmaKate]

I think this is a cool theory. I can't believe they worked so hard to figure it out. hmmm maybe richard is from all they back to the time of the black rock and was on the ship?

[celtic1959]

I like this theory, it makes some sense.
I dont know if this has anything to do with this, remember the milk carton that had Walt's picture as a missing child? Could he have time traveled before?

[bunnydixon]

what ep is that from?

[islander]

i like the two timeline theory, but i have a problem with the assumption dharma just happens to 'invent' a time machine. (how convenient!) i think the writers will be more creative than that, and we'll see dharma discovered some naturally occuring time/space phenomina that they attempted to control....just my theory.

[bunnydixon]

that does seem more plausible islander.

[celtic1959]

bunnydixon-
In season 2x04 there is a dream sequence with Hurley that shows him drinking from a milk carton with a picture of Walt as a missing child.

[decarlod]

Here is a quote from the theory

"Unfortunately, back in 2004 on the original timeline, the plane has actually crashed in the middle of the ocean, where the island used to be. You see, the island only currently exists in 2000, and is likely destroyed before 2004, thus it will NEVER exist to anyone who’s living in the real world post 2004. That is why Naomi pointed out that the survivors of 815 were found on the ocean floor after the crash. To be more specific, in 2004, the plane was “duplicated.” One version of the plane now exists on the island in 2000, and the other is crashed in the ocean in 2004. Thus, fate would rule that no matter what happens to our heroes, they are going to die if they ever reach the date of their plane crash in 2004."

As Jack is giving his testimony he says he met kate on the date of the crash. So he would be giving his testimony after the date of the original crash. If this theory is true then how is this happening?

[Rafe]

I think I cracked this theory...If the island was destroyed PRE 2004 then how could our "heroes" return home being that this island was destroyed before or during their stay. If you can explain this, you don't need glasses.