Hoth - Daniel and Penny - Twins??

[hurleysgurl]

Everyone agrees that Daniel and Penny are 1/2 brother and sister. I am going a step beyond that. In the second Star Wars movie, it ends with Luke finding out about his father. Leia was his twin sister. They were separated at birth to keep them safe. If one were killed, perhaps the other would survive. I think Daniel and Penny are twins. I don't know why they were separated, other than Ben obviously has it in for Charles, and perhaps would want to kill both of his children. What do you think?

[TXAgg]

Just like anyting else, it's sounds like it would be pretty interesting and definitally possible.

I guess someone would have to track down penny's age. I think a earlier thread had put Dan's DOB somewhere around 1975.

But then again, Ben accused Charles of having a child off the island while Charles was being taken to the sub... I figured then that they were talking about Penny, but who knows...

[bunnydixon]

im inclined to agree that penny is the child born off the island.

[navyguy]

Everyone agrees that Daniel and Penny are 1/2 brother and sister. I am going a step beyond that. In the second Star Wars movie, it ends with Luke finding out about his father. Leia was his twin sister. They were separated at birth to keep them safe. If one were killed, perhaps the other would survive. I think Daniel and Penny are twins. I don't know why they were separated, other than Ben obviously has it in for Charles, and perhaps would want to kill both of his children. What do you think?

There is one thing about that tho. We know that Charles when Charles was exiled Ben had said he had a child with an "outsider". So Either Penny and Daniel had 2 different mothers OR Ellie was exiled or left the island before Charles, and he left to be with her.

So Daniel might very well have been born on the island...altho he didn't have any nosebleeds....

[Panda]

So Daniel might very well have been born on the island...altho he didn't have any nosebleeds....

Do you think the nosebleeds are related to if someone was born on the Island or not?
If so, than Julliet and Sawyer were born on the Island as well?

[smthng2dowthlost]

Do you think the nosebleeds are related to if someone was born on the Island or not?
If so, than Julliet and Sawyer were born on the Island as well?

Duration of time on the island I think not whether you were born there, again I think .

[Workman]

If Daniel loses a hand a creates a mechanical one to replace it...I'm gonna lose it.

[Epy]

If Daniel loses a hand a creates a mechanical one to replace it...I'm gonna lose it.

Or maybe a mechanical foot. ;)

I'm going to have to agree with the Penny was born off the island theory.

[Lostdude2341]

Maybe him going off island and having a baby was a fabricated story by Ben. He's done worse things.... I don't belive myself but I just thought I would throw it out there. lol :D