Who is pure?

[delfrio]

Apologies if this has come up... it's not really a S5 question, but maybe worth talking about before the season finale.

According to Mikhail in an earlier episode, Jacob makes the lists, though we see Ben tell Ethan and Goodwin to make lists about 815. My question is -- who was on those lists that didn't get taken?

I am not sure about these, but it seems like we have strong hints that these are:

Eko
Locke
And possibly Claire.

Anyone else we know of?

[smthng2dowthlost]

Apologies if this has come up... it's not really a S5 question, but maybe worth talking about before the season finale.

According to Mikhail in an earlier episode, Jacob makes the lists, though we see Ben tell Ethan and Goodwin to make lists about 815. My question is -- who was on those lists that didn't get taken?

I am not sure about these, but it seems like we have strong hints that these are:

Eko
Locke
And possibly Claire.

Anyone else we know of?

I don't think eko was pure because the smoke slammed him into those trees. BUt I would go locke walt and aaron. Walt actually got taken tand they almost took aaron Maybe locke is the only one left to take.

Side question but related I think Why would they wait so long to take cindy?

[delfrio]

Eko was pure because he said two men tried to take him, but he killed them. Apparently being bad in your earlier life doesn't mean you are off the list.

[smthng2dowthlost]

Eko was pure because he said two men tried to take him, but he killed them. Apparently being bad in your earlier life doesn't mean you are off the list.

Goodwin told us the stategy though, rough quote "the first night they took the strongest of us all atheltic, well built, threats." They needed somebody to build the runway right. eko was the biggest physical threat to anybody on the island. the seventh or ninth night they took the kids and the people on the list eko was the first night.