So, Claudia is the boys' real mom. Stands to reason that their dad was on the boat too (thanks, LM!). Did he die on the ship? On island? If he was alive, did he know about his sons? Will we see more of this plot line from last week?
And, if I were from Indiana, should I have titled this thread "Hoosier Daddy"?
EDIT: does it even matter who the dad is? Was it divine intervention?