Question about Charlotte!

[rip-charlie]

Why has she not told anyone in Jacks group or her own people about Ben's Spy on the boat? who is she really with?

[bunnydixon]

well if its ben spy - how would charlotte know - did she hear ben say he had a spy on the boat?

[islander]

Charlotte was tracking Dharma polar bears so it seems her primary mission has something to do with the DI.

For Charlotte to know Ben's spy, wouldn't either Ben or the spy have to tell her/show her who the spy is? I don't know how that would have happened.

[lilsev42]

She has no idea who it is?

[rip-charlie]

Originally Posted by islander

Charlotte was tracking Dharma polar bears so it seems her primary mission has something to do with the DI.

For Charlotte to know Ben's spy, wouldn't either Ben or the spy have to tell her/show her who the spy is? I don't know how that would have happened.

no i swear she was there when Ben said i have a spy on the boat. after he shot her! when he knew all of her info. i might be wrong.

[dumbwhitey]

Originally Posted by rip-charlie

no i swear she was there when Ben said i have a spy on the boat. after he shot her! when he knew all of her info. i might be wrong.

Yeah, Ben did say that infront of Charlotte. Ben called her out, said her name, blah, blah, blah. Locke asked how he knew that. That's when Ben said, "I have a man on their boat"

[rip-charlie]

Originally Posted by dumbwhitey

Yeah, Ben did say that infront of Charlotte. Ben called her out, said her name, blah, blah, blah. Locke asked how he knew that. That's when Ben said, "I have a man on their boat"

thank you i thought i was going crazy!!!

[thelawgiver]

Right. Good observation. You would think that Charlotte would have told Frank before he flew the chopper back. Or mentioned it to Faraday. Or during any one of the phone calls. There was some discussion that Ben shot Charlotte knowing that she had a bullet-proof vest, just maintain the charade that she may be working with him

[rip-charlie]

Originally Posted by thelawgiver

Right. Good observation. You would think that Charlotte would have told Frank before he flew the chopper back. Or mentioned it to Faraday. Or during any one of the phone calls. There was some discussion that Ben shot Charlotte knowing that she had a bullet-proof vest, just maintain the charade that she may be working with him

that is what i'm saying i don't know why she has not said anything. is there still more to the story of why they are there?

[thelawgiver]

Things against this theory:

-Ben said he had a "man" on the boat, not woman or person
-The person's on the boat, not the island
-Charlotte seemed semi-shocked that Ben knew so much about her
-Charlotte may not have said anything, because Jack or Kate was always around during calls and demanded they be on speaker, so she did not want them to know that Ben said he had a mole.