Kate died in the car crash
Kate's mom did die of cancer
John died in his fall
Hurley died in the walkway collapse
Claire was killed with her mom
Charlie overdosed
Sayid was killed in the raid on the torture barracks
Ana Lucia was killed by the punk
Libby committed suicide
Jack had an accident and died
What if they all did previously die before they got to the island?
Desmond was killled in the service and on and on.....
Then Hurley's statement would make sense.
Somehow they all had unfinished business and... ?
I know there has been talk about this before and I'm willing to be bludgeoned for this , but what if?
I'm saying that if they all died in some violent way and it wasn't their time to go, then maybe a part of them didn't completely die. They had unfinished business. There was an alternative dimension in which they were allowed to keep going-all related to the island. Fate has given them a second chance to work it out. That is why Michael cannot die. Jack cannot off himself, etc. Or something like that. the island choses them. They are not supposed to leave! I'm just trying to figure it out , too.
Maybe Rose and Bernard had a suicide pact as other bonded couples before them have done in real life. We've had to see our characters dealing with some very heavy issues. There's no theory that explains everything and this one doesn't either. Just putting it out there for the shooting gallery.Hah hah.
I'm saying that if they all died in some violent way and it wasn't their time to go, then maybe a part of them didn't completely die. They had unfinished business. There was an alternative dimension in which they were allowed to keep going-all related to the island. Fate has given them a second chance to work it out. That is why Michael cannot die. Jack cannot off himself, etc. Or something like that. the island choses them. They are not supposed to leave! I'm just trying to figure it out , too.
Maybe Rose and Bernard had a suicide pact as other bonded couples before them have done in real life. We've had to see our characters dealing with some very heavy issues. There's no theory that explains everything and this one doesn't either. Just putting it out there for the shooting gallery.Hah hah.
Hey, at least we are all thinking and discussing our views and opinions, thats what this forum is about. I think the passengers of 815 were in fact alive when the plane took off from Sydney. I think they were supposed to die in the crash, and when they didn't the Island started to use them until their "roles", "destinies", "fates" (whatever you want to call it), were fulfilled before they could "go on".
I'm saying that if they all died in some violent way and it wasn't their time to go, then maybe a part of them didn't completely die. They had unfinished business. There was an alternative dimension in which they were allowed to keep going-all related to the island. Fate has given them a second chance to work it out. That is why Michael cannot die. Jack cannot off himself, etc. Or something like that. the island choses them. They are not supposed to leave! I'm just trying to figure it out , too.
Maybe Rose and Bernard had a suicide pact as other bonded couples before them have done in real life. We've had to see our characters dealing with some very heavy issues. There's no theory that explains everything and this one doesn't either. Just putting it out there for the shooting gallery.Hah hah.
It sounds like you're bringing up the "Purgatory" theory again. I'm pretty sure Carlton Cuse and Damon Lindelof have disputed that theory in multiply interviews. They've been adamant that this is not Purgatory.
__________________ "Have fun stormin' the castle!!".
The Philippines is the key. Australia is just a front.
That's exactly what I love about this forum. I don't love this idea of them being dead so when I put it out there I guess I secretly want to believe that this is just crazy. I'm hoping someone can point out why or why not and I'll argue my points until there's a dead end or nowhere to go.
That's exactly what I love about this forum. I don't love this idea of them being dead so when I put it out there I guess I secretly want to believe that this is just crazy. I'm hoping someone can point out why or why not and I'll argue my points until there's a dead end or nowhere to go.
but what if they are dead, the island is just delaying their deaths because of the time difference
__________________
Presumption equals stagnation. Never be satisfied with answers until all the questions run dry~Nathale Kennedy
That's exactly what I love about this forum. I don't love this idea of them being dead so when I put it out there I guess I secretly want to believe that this is just crazy. I'm hoping someone can point out why or why not and I'll argue my points until there's a dead end or nowhere to go.
I hear what you're saying. Even though the producers have eliminated the possibility of a "purgatory" like situation, I still think the series is leaning close to it. I agree, it seems like the main theme around this show is redemption, second chances, recognizing the right choices and acting on them.
__________________ "Have fun stormin' the castle!!".
The Philippines is the key. Australia is just a front.
I NEVER think what the producers say is written in stone. I think this is a great theory. It would make sense with what Hurley said. I want to go back and look to see if you can actually see Jack in the mirror when Kate is holding it. Why doesn't Jack have a scar anymore?
What IF.......
Linear Mode
