Originally Posted by thelawgiver
I think it is Richard on the boat. And after the Chooper went for the island. A group of others boarded and took over the freighter.
I like this theory, This is Quite Believable and sound like somthing Ben would plan.
then again, it could be micael as locke saw walt? Unless the Vision of walt Was Jacob Messing with Johns head. If you understand what im saying.