Originally Posted by ortrules
I don't think Phil is up to anything, I just think he's picking up on the subtle bits of information that Kate and Jack don't know.
When he questioned Kate, he asked who her recruiter was and she couldn't answer. Then when Jack asked him where Sawyer was, he asked for James LaFleur, and Phil said something like "he hates when people call him James". I think he figured that it was odd that the new girl doesn't know her recruiter and is added at the last minute, and then Jack (who shouldn't really know LaFleur) calls him a name he hates.
Yeah, exactly.. To Phil, Kate and Jack were both being weird and suspicious.. If you were just recruited to Dharma you probably wouldn't hesitate when someone asks who your recruiter is, and you probably wouldn't be looking for the Head of Security on your first day, you'd be hanging out with other new recruits.