When Richard tells Sun

[it's never been easy]

When Richard tells Sun hew saw them all die in 1977 isn't he wondering how he saw them all in 2004 again. I mean, the Others captured Kate, Sawyer, Jack, Hurley and received the passenger manifests from the plane. Also Richard made a deal with Sayid and Kate to let them off the island after Richard is shown to have killed Keamy. Very confusing

[RussellEarl3]

Richard has known that something is up with Time travel and the Losties since 1954, but it appears he doesn't have a clue what it is. If Richard is the mamn behind the curtain he is doing a great job of hiding it.

[2cansam]

I think the writers have thrown to many angles in the story and cant back track their own plot. Last nights episode was stupid. How can Richard act like he doesn't seem to know what the hell is going on after he had already meet all these people thru time. Then through out the whole seris of Lost Richard has always acted as if John was the chosen one and now Richard is acting as if he is not the one and leaning toward Ben again WTF ?

[it's never been easy]

could not agree more--All of a sudden Locke is becoming a problem. I though they were so happy to have him " Welcome home John" in season 4 finale Richard says-now Why are you here type of thing. Way too many questions and problems and people right now